-----BEGIN PGP SIGNED MESSAGE----- Hash: SHA1 Tuesday, November 25, 2003, 10:12:27 PM, I wrote:
LG>> Attached is a custom rule file. It has been working rather well and LG>> I will be increasing the score from 0.5 to 1.0. The cf file also has LG>> some rules looking for words obfuscated by pipes. They have been LG>> working well also. RM> FYI, My masscheck results with your rules (run against my corpus of RM> 58,857 emails). Final number on each line is what I would initially score RM> them based on these hits (per my algorithm posted at RM> http://www.exit0.us/index.php/RM_RuleScoring -- most sites should RM> probably score these lower, and I would probably want to do a 2-pass or RM> 3-pass GA on these to refine the scores myself). Ran a second mass-check pass, assigning those scores (repeated below), and with those scores, * I had no FPs based on these rules -- highest score in any ham was less than 6.0 out of 9.0 * These rules by themselves, with these scores, correctly flagged 263 as spam with scores of 9.0 or higher. I'm guessing that others could take my scores, adjust for threshold and other rules, and use these rules productively. If you score spam at 5.0, then you'd want to multiply each of my scores by 5/9 (or maybe a little less, on the theory that other rules should hit the spam also). My own hesitation rests with that "and other rules" part ... If this ruleset by itself can bring a ham to (say) 4.0 of 9.0, and that ham matches 5.0 worth of rules without this ruleset, it'll then be wrongly flagged as spam. I am just about at the point where I can do a mass-check including all of my custom rules, but I haven't yet figured out how to incorporate all of the distributed rules in that mass-check. I'm supplying my ruleset in testdir/spamassassin/user_prefs, and pointing to that directory using the -c parameter to mass-check. If I were to copy all of the 2.60 *.cf rules files into that testdir/spamassassin directory, would that activate the default rules for the mass-check test? Bob Menschel RM> MY_RBDY_PDS_1P3 -- 375s / 22h -- 1.163 RM> MY_RBDY_PDS_1P4 -- 365s / 5h -- 1.608 RM> MY_RBDY_PDS_1P5 -- 210s / 3h -- 1.700 RM> MY_RBDY_PDS_1P6 -- 165s / 2h -- 0.550 RM> MY_RBDY_PDS_1P7 -- 88s / 0h -- 1.880 RM> MY_RBDY_PDS_1P8 -- 121s / 4h -- 1.302 RM> MY_RBDY_PDS_2P2 -- 168s / 14h -- 1.112 RM> MY_RBDY_PDS_2P3 -- 105s / 45h -- 0.228 RM> MY_RBDY_PDS_2P4 -- 311s / 14h -- 1.207 RM> MY_RBDY_PDS_2P5 -- 56s / 7h -- 0.700 RM> MY_RBDY_PDS_2P6 -- 161s / 8h -- 1.179 RM> MY_RBDY_PDS_2P7 -- 89s / 5h -- 1.148 RM> MY_RBDY_PDS_2P8 -- 4s / 5h -- 0.067 RM> MY_RBDY_PDS_3P1 -- 200s / 15h -- 1.125 RM> MY_RBDY_PDS_3P2 -- 173s / 25h -- 6.654 RM> MY_RBDY_PDS_3P3 -- 179s / 58h -- 0.303 RM> MY_RBDY_PDS_3P4 -- 74s / 15h -- 0.463 RM> MY_RBDY_PDS_3P5 -- 195s / 12h -- 1.150 RM> MY_RBDY_PDS_3P6 -- 43s / 5h -- 0.717 RM> MY_RBDY_PDS_3P7 -- 3s / 5h -- 0.050 RM> MY_RBDY_PDS_3P8 -- 42s / 49h -- 0.084 RM> MY_RBDY_PDS_4P1 -- 285s / 32h -- 0.864 RM> MY_RBDY_PDS_4P2 -- 417s / 21h -- 1.190 RM> MY_RBDY_PDS_4P3 -- 259s / 82h -- 0.312 RM> MY_RBDY_PDS_4P4 -- 160s / 26h -- 0.593 RM> MY_RBDY_PDS_4P5 -- 56s / 17h -- 0.311 RM> MY_RBDY_PDS_4P6 -- 7s / 0h -- 0.700 RM> MY_RBDY_PDS_4P7 -- 3s / 12h -- 0.023 RM> MY_RBDY_PDS_4P8 -- 2s / 0h -- 0.200 RM> MY_RBDY_PDS_5P1 -- 84s / 21h -- 0.382 RM> MY_RBDY_PDS_5P3 -- 99s / 464h -- 0.021 RM> MY_RBDY_PDS_5P5 -- 81s / 12h -- 0.623 RM> MY_RBDY_PDS_6P6 -- 99s / 464h -- 0.021 RM> MY_HDR_PDS_1P5 -- 140s / 0h -- 2.400 RM> MY_HDR_PDS_2P1 -- 244s / 3h -- 1.610 RM> MY_HDR_PDS_2P4 -- 176s / 13h -- 1.126 RM> MY_HDR_PDS_3P2 -- 308s / 9h -- 1.308 RM> MY_HDR_PDS_3P3 -- 607s / 528h -- 0.115 RM> MY_HDR_PDS_3P5 -- 108s / 0h -- 2.080 RM> MY_HDR_PDS_3P8 -- 73s / 0h -- 1.730 RM> MY_HDR_PDS_4P3 -- 481s / 519h -- 0.093 RM> MY_HDR_PDS_4P4 -- 114s / 13h -- 0.814 RM> MY_HDR_PDS_4P5 -- 82s / 0h -- 1.820 RM> MY_HDR_PDS_5P1 -- 171s / 0h -- 2.710 RM> MY_HDR_PDS_6P1 -- 159s / 0h -- 2.590 RM> MY_HDR_PDS_6P2 -- 122s / 9h -- 1.122 RM> MY_BDY_PIPE_S233S -- 17s / 0h -- 1.170 RM> MY_BDY_PIPE_S23S -- 35s / 0h -- 1.350 RM> MY_BDY_PIPE_S23C -- 17s / 0h -- 1.170 RM> MY_BDY_PIPE_S24S -- 42s / 0h -- 1.420 RM> MY_BDY_PIPE_S34P -- 0s / 0h -- 0.100 RM> MY_HDR_PIPE_S233S -- 0s / 0h -- 0.100 RM> MY_HDR_PIPE_S23S -- 0s / 0h -- 0.100 RM> MY_HDR_PIPE_S23C -- 0s / 0h -- 0.100 RM> MY_HDR_PIPE_S24S -- 0s / 0h -- 0.100 RM> MY_HDR_PIPE_S34P -- 0s / 0h -- 0.100 -----BEGIN PGP SIGNATURE----- Version: PGP 8.0 iQA/AwUBP8WxyZebK8E4qh1HEQIUgwCeIJtF3dmjXk2mtzUXMWNG90QVKf8An1l/ 9IZEi38AoIkjpyCTFYP0gH9k =o8v1 -----END PGP SIGNATURE----- ------------------------------------------------------- This SF.net email is sponsored by: SF.net Giveback Program. Does SourceForge.net help you be more productive? Does it help you create better code? SHARE THE LOVE, and help us help YOU! Click Here: http://sourceforge.net/donate/ _______________________________________________ Spamassassin-talk mailing list [EMAIL PROTECTED] https://lists.sourceforge.net/lists/listinfo/spamassassin-talk
