Re: [zfs-discuss] raidz vs raid5 clarity needed

2009-12-29 Thread Brad
@ross "If the write doesn't span the whole stripe width then there is a read of the parity chunk, write of the block and a write of the parity chunk which is the write hole penalty/vulnerability, and is 3 operations (if the data spans more then 1 chunk then it is written in parallel so you can thi

Re: [zfs-discuss] raidz vs raid5 clarity needed

2009-12-29 Thread Ross Walker
On Dec 29, 2009, at 5:37 PM, Brad wrote: Hi! I'm attempting to understand the pros/cons between raid5 and raidz after running into a performance issue with Oracle on zfs (http://opensolaris.org/jive/thread.jspa?threadID=120703&tstart=0 ). I would appreciate some feedback on what I've und

Re: [zfs-discuss] raidz vs raid5 clarity needed

2009-12-29 Thread A Darren Dunham
On Tue, Dec 29, 2009 at 02:37:20PM -0800, Brad wrote: > I would appreciate some feedback on what I've understood so far: > > WRITES > > raid5 - A FS block is written on a single disk (or multiple disks depending on size data???) There is no direct relationship between a filesystem and the RAID s

[zfs-discuss] raidz vs raid5 clarity needed

2009-12-29 Thread Brad
Hi! I'm attempting to understand the pros/cons between raid5 and raidz after running into a performance issue with Oracle on zfs (http://opensolaris.org/jive/thread.jspa?threadID=120703&tstart=0). I would appreciate some feedback on what I've understood so far: WRITES raid5 - A FS block is