Re: [zfs-discuss] OpenSolaris, ZFS and Hardware RAID,

2008-02-10 Thread Jonathan Loran
Anton B. Rang wrote: Careful here. If your workload is unpredictable, RAID 6 (and RAID 5) for that matter will break down under highly randomized write loads. Oh? What precisely do you mean by "break down"? RAID 5's write performance is well-understood and it's used successfully in

Re: [zfs-discuss] OpenSolaris, ZFS and Hardware RAID, a recipe for success?

2008-02-10 Thread Richard Elling
Kyle McDonald wrote: > Richard Elling wrote: > >> Nick wrote: >> >> >>> I have been tasked with putting together a storage solution for use in a >>> virtualization setup, serving NFS, CIFS, and iSCSI, over GigE. I've >>> inherited a few components to work with: >>> >>> x86 dual cor

Re: [zfs-discuss] OpenSolaris, ZFS and Hardware RAID,

2008-02-10 Thread Anton B. Rang
> Careful here.  If your workload is unpredictable, RAID 6 (and RAID 5) > for that matter will break down under highly randomized write loads.  Oh? What precisely do you mean by "break down"? RAID 5's write performance is well-understood and it's used successfully in many installations for rand

Re: [zfs-discuss] OpenSolaris, ZFS and Hardware RAID, a recipe for success?

2008-02-10 Thread Kyle McDonald
Richard Elling wrote: > Nick wrote: > >> I have been tasked with putting together a storage solution for use in a >> virtualization setup, serving NFS, CIFS, and iSCSI, over GigE. I've >> inherited a few components to work with: >> >> x86 dual core server , 512MB LSI-ELP RAID card >>

Re: [zfs-discuss] OpenSolaris, ZFS and Hardware RAID,

2008-02-10 Thread Nick
> > On Feb 10, 2008 9:06 > AM, Jonathan Loran < href="mailto:[EMAIL PROTECTED]">[EMAIL PROTECTED] > ley.edu> wrote: class="gmail_quote" style="border-left: 1px solid > rgb(204, 204, 204); margin: 0pt 0pt 0pt 0.8ex; > padding-left: 1ex;"> > > > > > div bgcolor="#ff" text="#00"> > >

Re: [zfs-discuss] OpenSolaris, ZFS and Hardware RAID, a recipe for success?

2008-02-10 Thread Johan Hartzenberg
On Feb 10, 2008 9:06 AM, Jonathan Loran <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> wrote: > > > Richard Elling wrote: > > Nick wrote: > > > Using the RAID cards capability for RAID6 sounds attractive? > > > > Assuming the card works well with Solaris, this sounds like a > reasonable solution. > > > > Careful her

Re: [zfs-discuss] OpenSolaris, ZFS and Hardware RAID,

2008-02-10 Thread Nick
The workload will be generated by a gaggle of virtual machines, most of which I expect to be running the normal mix of Microsoft/Office type applications (of which I expect MS-Exchange to be the most demanding). I gather the LSI card allows you to dedicate the entire NVRAM cache to writes shou

Re: [zfs-discuss] OpenSolaris, ZFS and Hardware RAID, a recipe for success?

2008-02-09 Thread Jonathan Loran
Richard Elling wrote: Nick wrote: Using the RAID cards capability for RAID6 sounds attractive? Assuming the card works well with Solaris, this sounds like a reasonable solution. Careful here. If your workload is unpredictable, RAID 6 (and RAID 5) for that matter wil

Re: [zfs-discuss] OpenSolaris, ZFS and Hardware RAID, a recipe for success?

2008-02-09 Thread Richard Elling
Nick wrote: > I have been tasked with putting together a storage solution for use in a > virtualization setup, serving NFS, CIFS, and iSCSI, over GigE. I've inherited > a few components to work with: > > x86 dual core server , 512MB LSI-ELP RAID card > 12 x 300GB 15Krpm SAS disks

[zfs-discuss] OpenSolaris, ZFS and Hardware RAID, a recipe for success?

2008-02-09 Thread Nick
I have been tasked with putting together a storage solution for use in a virtualization setup, serving NFS, CIFS, and iSCSI, over GigE. I've inherited a few components to work with: x86 dual core server , 512MB LSI-ELP RAID card 12 x 300GB 15Krpm SAS disks & array 2GB