Re: [WiX-users] Crystal Reports Merge Module Installation Woes

2008-01-04 Thread Szentpali Janos
Bob Arnson írta: > Szentpali Janos wrote: >> Can you suggest some strategy to help one install components that do not >> come in msi-s or msm-s but that are shared/common components that >> could/would possibly be installed by non msi setups > > If you're not using stable component IDs through MSI,

Re: [WiX-users] Crystal Reports Merge Module Installation Woes

2008-01-04 Thread Bob Arnson
Szentpali Janos wrote: > Can you suggest some strategy to help one install components that do not > come in msi-s or msm-s but that are shared/common components that > could/would possibly be installed by non msi setups If you're not using stable component IDs through MSI, the closest you'll get

Re: [WiX-users] Crystal Reports Merge Module Installation Woes

2008-01-03 Thread Szentpali Janos
Bob Arnson írta: > Szentpali Janos wrote: >> Does that mean that the same file, installed by two unrelated setup >> packages into the same path, with two distinct component and file ids >> (guids) will still be correctly uninstalled/managed? > > No, that's what component rules are about. The compo

Re: [WiX-users] Crystal Reports Merge Module Installation Woes

2008-01-03 Thread Bob Arnson
Szentpali Janos wrote: > Does that mean that the same file, installed by two unrelated setup > packages into the same path, with two distinct component and file ids > (guids) will still be correctly uninstalled/managed? No, that's what component rules are about. The component GUID and resource I

Re: [WiX-users] Crystal Reports Merge Module Installation Woes

2008-01-03 Thread Szentpali Janos
Bob Arnson írta: > Szentpali Janos wrote: >> "Merge modules are generally now considered bad practice..." If this >> is true than what is the point of the whole MSI system? I mean if I >> have a 3rd party component (x.dll) that 4th party and 5th party are >> using too, how does the system decide th

Re: [WiX-users] Crystal Reports Merge Module Installation Woes

2008-01-02 Thread Bob Arnson
Szentpali Janos wrote: > "Merge modules are generally now considered bad practice..." > If this is true than what is the point of the whole MSI system? I mean if I > have a 3rd party component (x.dll) that 4th party and 5th party are using > too, how does the system decide that the x.dll compone

Re: [WiX-users] Crystal Reports Merge Module Installation Woes

2007-12-31 Thread greenaj
Ugh, I just send this reply but forgort to include the Subject: Anyway, Thanks. I did get everything working with the merge module, and I did find the standalone MSI alternative to the merge module. I hope that the licensing is the same with the XTal MSI as with the merge module. I do use Orca

Re: [WiX-users] Crystal Reports Merge Module Installation Woes

2007-12-30 Thread Szentpali Janos
"Merge modules are generally now considered bad practice..." If this is true than what is the point of the whole MSI system? I mean if I have a 3rd party component (x.dll) that 4th party and 5th party are using too, how does the system decide that the x.dll component installed by the 4th party'

Re: [WiX-users] Crystal Reports Merge Module Installation Woes

2007-12-30 Thread Mike Dimmick
Merge modules are generally now considered bad practice - they become impossible to service, because the module does not retain its identity. The only way to service them is to patch the products which have merged the module. Crystal Reports had a security patch earlier this year: http://www.micros