Re: [Wireshark-dev] Feature: option to open windows as tabs

2018-05-07 Thread Roland Knall
I think before we submit this patch, we should agree on a general UI concept going forward. TL;DR: I think tabs for the main window is the wrong approach and will alienate a lot of users There are basically three main uses for tabs in an application (besides from preference dialogs). The first

Re: [Wireshark-dev] Feature: option to open windows as tabs

2018-05-07 Thread Paul Offord
A couple of things I’ve noted. Microsoft Message Analyzer uses tabs in the main window but I confess I don’t think I’ve used them to look at multiple traces. Second point, maybe dockable windows would be better. We use Telerik for Workbench and it provides a typical dockable window mechanism.

Re: [Wireshark-dev] Feature: option to open windows as tabs

2018-05-07 Thread Michał Łabędzki
> One last (but important) argument is screen size. A lot of people have big > screens now. The tabbed approach for the main window really only makes sense > on smaller screens. Also, I have a big screen, but it is my feature. I really want to collect windows in one place to speed up work (like

Re: [Wireshark-dev] Feature: option to open windows as tabs

2018-05-07 Thread Roland Knall
I am not trying to force users to use anything. The whole idea with dockable windows started from a point to be able to use the exact same layout functionality as today, but with a more comfortable configuration. And I do not think you can compare the layout preferences to your idea. Your idea goe