Re: [vpp-dev] Discussion Topic: creating demo branches in git.fd.io/vpp

2017-11-15 Thread Ole Troan (otroan)
> The concern would be that without CI you have very limited visibility into > the impact of the patches pre-merge. The automation at fd.io does a *lot* > for you… Absolutely. For the hackathons CI was an order or two of magnitude too slow. And we would be doing the testing there and then. I d

Re: [vpp-dev] Discussion Topic: creating demo branches in git.fd.io/vpp

2017-11-15 Thread Ed Warnicke
Ole, The concern would be that without CI you have very limited visibility into the impact of the patches pre-merge. The automation at fd.io does a *lot* for you... Ed On Wed, Nov 15, 2017 at 3:50 PM Jon Loeliger wrote: > On Wed, Nov 15, 2017 at 4:17 PM, Dave Wallace > wrote: > >> Folks, >>

Re: [vpp-dev] Discussion Topic: creating demo branches in git.fd.io/vpp

2017-11-15 Thread Jim Thompson
(dbarach) > ; Keith Burns (krb) ; Florin Coras > (fcoras) ; John Lo (loj) ; Luke, Chris > ; Damjan Marion ; Neale > Ranns (nranns) ; vpp-dev@lists.fd.io > Subject: Re: [vpp-dev] Discussion Topic: creating demo branches in > git.fd.io/vpp > > Just as a data-point. >

Re: [vpp-dev] Discussion Topic: creating demo branches in git.fd.io/vpp

2017-11-15 Thread Dave Barach (dbarach)
) ; vpp-dev@lists.fd.io Subject: Re: [vpp-dev] Discussion Topic: creating demo branches in git.fd.io/vpp Just as a data-point. What we have done for IETF hackathons is to create a branch on github. E.g: https://github.com/vpp-dev/vpp/tree/ietf100-nat This allows us to do "high speed collabor

Re: [vpp-dev] Discussion Topic: creating demo branches in git.fd.io/vpp

2017-11-15 Thread Jon Loeliger
On Wed, Nov 15, 2017 at 4:17 PM, Dave Wallace wrote: > Folks, > > Per the action item from this yesterday's VPP weekly meeting, I'm asking > for opinions from the VPP community on allowing the creation of demo > branches in the VPP git repo. > > ... > > Pro: Will allow utilization of LF infra to

Re: [vpp-dev] Discussion Topic: creating demo branches in git.fd.io/vpp

2017-11-15 Thread Ole Troan
Just as a data-point. What we have done for IETF hackathons is to create a branch on github. E.g: https://github.com/vpp-dev/vpp/tree/ietf100-nat This allows us to do "high speed collaboration". Then cherry pick what has value after the event. Perhaps something similar could be done for "demos"?

Re: [vpp-dev] Discussion Topic: creating demo branches in git.fd.io/vpp

2017-11-15 Thread Dave Barach (dbarach)
I have a mild preference that we avoid creating demo branches in the master vpp repo. When faced with similar requirements, I’ve added branch(es) to ephemeral downstream mirrors. I suppose one could destroy demo branches in the master vpp repo, but “something could go wrong...” Thoughts? Than