Re: T5 Dispatcher: How to correctly order the Pipeline

2010-08-02 Thread Pierce Wetter
On Jul 31, 2010, at 2:13 AM, Daniel Henze wrote: > Thanks Kalle and Pierce for your feedback, it's interesting to read a little > more about other experiences. I can completely understand the login form > issue, something I stopped considering after a short period of time. The > tynamo project

Re: T5 Dispatcher: How to correctly order the Pipeline

2010-07-31 Thread Daniel Henze
Thanks Kalle and Pierce for your feedback, it's interesting to read a little more about other experiences. I can completely understand the login form issue, something I stopped considering after a short period of time. The tynamo project has some really interesting projects and it seems securit

Re: T5 Dispatcher: How to correctly order the Pipeline

2010-07-30 Thread Pierce Wetter
I followed a similar path. I started trying to use tapestry-spring-security, couldn't figure out how to customize the login form, and switch to Kalle's tapestry-security project, and I'm now a happy customer, and I ended up contributing back to the tapestry-security project some components.

Re: T5 Dispatcher: How to correctly order the Pipeline

2010-07-30 Thread Kalle Korhonen
I'm completely biased of course so feel free to disregard, but: I used to be a long time user of Acegi Security (now Spring Security) but finally got fed up with the peculiarities of the framework and the inherent inflexibility for supporting some of the more elaborate security models. I looked aro

Re: T5 Dispatcher: How to correctly order the Pipeline

2010-07-30 Thread Daniel Henze
Well, I did have a glance at it the time I was looking for a security solution. But to me it appeared the easiest to go with tapestry-spring-security, mainly due to the ease of initial integration. The documentation of tynamos tapestry-seems to be quite good as well. From looking at the example

Re: T5 Dispatcher: How to correctly order the Pipeline

2010-07-30 Thread Christophe Cordenier
Hi Have you looked in to tynamo security project ? 2010/7/30 Daniel Henze > Hi Christophe, > > yes, I have read that article before, but admit that I could not grasp all > the details by that time and therefore decided to go with > tapestry-spring-security. A lot of knowledge has been gained in

Re: T5 Dispatcher: How to correctly order the Pipeline

2010-07-30 Thread Daniel Henze
Hi Christophe, yes, I have read that article before, but admit that I could not grasp all the details by that time and therefore decided to go with tapestry-spring-security. A lot of knowledge has been gained in between though, so I will re-read and think about option 3 (re-implementing secur

Re: T5 Dispatcher: How to correctly order the Pipeline

2010-07-30 Thread Christophe Cordenier
Hi Have already read this article [1] from Howard, it explains how to secure an application via Annotations and shows the pipeline as well [1] http://tapestryjava.blogspot.com/2009/12/securing-tapestry-pages-with.html 2010/7/30 Daniel Henze > Hi everyone, > > I created a Service, contributede