Re: milter vs spamc

2024-01-15 Thread Mike Bostock via users
In your message regarding Re: milter vs spamc dated 15/01/2024, Mike Bostock said ... > In your message regarding Re: milter vs spamc dated 15/01/2024, Benoit > Panizzon said ... > > Hi > > > What are the pros and cons? > > In my opinion, an email should eith

Re: milter vs spamc

2024-01-15 Thread Mike Bostock via users
In your message regarding Re: milter vs spamc dated 15/01/2024, Benoit Panizzon said ... > Hi > > What are the pros and cons? > In my opinion, an email should either be received by a MTA and > delivered to the recipient, or rejected during the SMTP phase. Thanks everyone for

Re: milter vs spamc

2024-01-15 Thread Benoit Panizzon
Hi > The only con is that milter can't apply multiple SA settings when single > mail has multiple destination users - it only has to use single setting for > them. We found a way around this, we use MIMEDefang as Milter and have built database lookups in the config. Usually, per user SA settin

Re: milter vs spamc

2024-01-15 Thread Matus UHLAR - fantomas
On 14.01.24 22:22, Mike Bostock via users wrote: I currently have users set up with spamc called in .procmailrc However, I have quite a few aliases/redirects in sendmail virtusertable who are not being protected by Spamassassin. spamass-milter has setting for default user (-U username) that is

Re: milter vs spamc

2024-01-15 Thread Benoit Panizzon
Hi > What are the pros and cons? In my opinion, an email should either be received by a MTA and delivered to the recipient, or rejected during the SMTP phase. This eliminates: * Emails 'disappearing' (false positives as example) * Sending late bounces to fake sender when rejected by the LDA So

Re: milter vs spamc

2024-01-14 Thread Benny Pedersen
Mike Bostock via users skrev den 2024-01-14 23:22: I currently have users set up with spamc called in .procmailrc virtual users is hard to support then However, I have quite a few aliases/redirects in sendmail virtusertable who are not being protected by Spamassassin. good, move all system

milter vs spamc

2024-01-14 Thread Mike Bostock via users
I currently have users set up with spamc called in .procmailrc However, I have quite a few aliases/redirects in sendmail virtusertable who are not being protected by Spamassassin. Would I be better using the milter? What are the pros and cons? How do I redirect spam to a mailbox if I use the mi