Frank,
I don't think that the fix needs to necessarily follow the #12450 PR, we
can choose to start from scratch now that we know more about the issue.
If that PR is useful as a starting point, we can also include it, that is
up to you.
Greg
On Mon, Feb 6, 2023 at 10:21 AM Frank Grimes
wrote:
Hi Greg,
I actually just found the following comment on this PR for
https://issues.apache.org/jira/browse/KAFKA-13809:
https://github.com/apache/kafka/pull/12450
> we get the same behavior (KAFKA-9228 notwithstanding) by passing the original
>properties through to tasks transparently
It seems
Frank,
I think you're right that the KAFKA-9228 ticket doesn't capture every
possible reconfiguration that might result in a dropped restart.
The ticket calls out the FileStream connectors, which generate their
configurations by dropping unknown config values, which is relatively
uncommon.
This me
Hi Greg,
The "long-term inconsistency" we have observed is not with no tasks at all, but
instead with all the previously running tasks remaining in a running state but
with a previous config.
If I'm understanding the original bug report correctly, the scope of the
problem was thought to only af
Thanks David and Sophie!
Ismael
On Mon, Feb 6, 2023, 7:22 AM David Arthur wrote:
> I'd like to go ahead and close out this vote. There were three binding
> votes and one non-binding vote.
>
> Binding +1 PMC votes:
> * David Jacot
> * Bill Bejeck
> * Mickael Maison
>
> Non-binding community vote
I'd like to go ahead and close out this vote. There were three binding
votes and one non-binding vote.
Binding +1 PMC votes:
* David Jacot
* Bill Bejeck
* Mickael Maison
Non-binding community votes:
* Federico Valeri
There were no -1 votes.
The vote for Apache Kafka 3.4.0 RC2 passes.
Thanks to
