Re: [FRIDAY] Re: has struts reached the saturation

2006-03-19 Thread Dakota Jack
Heh, Xaymaca! Nice to hear from you. On 3/19/06, Vincent <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> wrote: > > :0 > * ^From: [EMAIL PROTECTED] > /dev/null > > > > Dakota Jack wrote: > > Here is a JSF big gun. At least now we know what this surprising new > > committer who seems to know nothing about Struts does; he re

Re: [FRIDAY] Re: has struts reached the saturation

2006-03-19 Thread Dakota Jack
I have expressed my "technical concerns" more than once. I have even had Craig agree with them, in a sense. JSF is built for those who are technically challenged and for tools. I don't think even Craig thinks that JSF is superior as a product for advanced webwork. Who knows anymore, however. L

Re: [FRIDAY] Re: has struts reached the saturation

2006-03-19 Thread Vincent
:0 * ^From: [EMAIL PROTECTED] /dev/null Dakota Jack wrote: Here is a JSF big gun. At least now we know what this surprising new committer who seems to know nothing about Struts does; he reads motivational books. On 3/19/06, Gary VanMatre <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> wrote: From: "Alexandre Poitras"

RE: Struts CMS ?

2006-03-19 Thread Roy, Ansuman
yeah I am using LenyaCMS for a major client but it's totally based on xsl, xsp, java, ant CMS produces static html pages that are picked up by several struts application. -Original Message- From: Alexandre Poitras [mailto:[EMAIL PROTECTED] Sent: Sunday, March 19, 2006 10:35 AM To: Struts

Re: Struts EJB 3 tutorial

2006-03-19 Thread Vincent
Actually, it's been my understanding that struts is pretty much a BYOM (Bring Your Own Model) kind of framework. Tutorials that show workable ways of abstracting out persistence to DAOs and such are always welcome to me. Like Ricks struts-spring-ibatis tutorial: http://www.learntechnology.net/stru

Re: [Shale] shale-mailreader could not be started

2006-03-19 Thread Michael Jouravlev
Do current automated builds of Shale Mailreader represent its finished or near-finished state, or it is still work in progress? Michael. - To unsubscribe, e-mail: [EMAIL PROTECTED] For additional commands, e-mail: [EMAIL PROTECTE

Re: has struts reached the saturation

2006-03-19 Thread Frank W. Zammetti
Welcome Jonathan! Better late than never :) Jonathan Revusky wrote: I think here we have to agree to disagree. I see there being a responsibility involved that you don't. It isn't like anyone can just come along and contribute, contrary to what we might want people to believe, because there

Re: [shale] how MyFaces's component do layout

2006-03-19 Thread [EMAIL PROTECTED]
I cannot find the place to download Clay. Does Clay exist inside Shale already? In the first few lines of documentation, it says Clay is similar to Tapestry and Facelets. If there are available products to use, does Clay closely clung to Shale or Struts? On 3/20/06, Alexandre Poitras <[EMAIL PRO

Re: [shale] how MyFaces's component do layout

2006-03-19 Thread Alexandre Poitras
I will let Gary or Craig answer this one but if you use Shale, Clay is your answer. On 3/19/06, [EMAIL PROTECTED] <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> wrote: > As I find JSF has h:subview or other h: component, > can I use JSF component only such that I can do without Tiles? > If yes, should it be h:subview or oth

Re: [FRIDAY] Re: has struts reached the saturation

2006-03-19 Thread Alexandre Poitras
What? You want me to discuss what I don't like in Tapestry or what I prefer in JSF? I have no real concerns about Tapestry, I just prefer the way some things are done in JSF. But I wouldn't be afraid of using Tapestry either, it is indeed a good framework. You are the one always bashing JSF, so exp

[shale] how MyFaces's component do layout

2006-03-19 Thread [EMAIL PROTECTED]
As I find JSF has h:subview or other h: component, can I use JSF component only such that I can do without Tiles? If yes, should it be h:subview or other component? Thanks

Re: has struts reached the saturation

2006-03-19 Thread Hey Nony Moose
perhaps this thread is now "has struts reached the obfuscation" - To unsubscribe, e-mail: [EMAIL PROTECTED] For additional commands, e-mail: [EMAIL PROTECTED]

Re: has struts reached the saturation

2006-03-19 Thread Paul Benedict
>> I think that any project has to have some coherent message ... >> to have such an incoherent message due to this Action/Shale >> bifurcation seems very negative. It just seems complicated and >> confused. Jonathan, I whole heartedly agree. I do not know who came up with the idea that "Struts"

Re: has struts reached the saturation

2006-03-19 Thread Hey Nony Moose
Jonathan Revusky wrote: > ... person who visits your website and starts looking at the > mail archive and so on has to be able to figure out quite quickly "WTF > is struts" and to have such an incoherent message due to this > Action/Shale bifurcation seems very negative. It just seems > complicat

Re: has struts reached the saturation

2006-03-19 Thread Jonathan Revusky
Frank W. Zammetti wrote: Ted Husted wrote: On 3/14/06, Frank W. Zammetti <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> wrote: but I to this day do not believe it was the motivation of the larger entities involved. True. If those "larger entities" had any say, we wouldn't be merging with WebWork. If anyone wanted p

Re: [FRIDAY] Re: has struts reached the saturation

2006-03-19 Thread Dakota Jack
You know, Gary, when you are advocating what has already been done well, Tapestry, under a new name, JSF, claiming to be the leading edge is not liable to lead to confidence in how you are finding your cheese. This is especially so when you have to try to sell the work by trying to wrangle the bra

Re: [FRIDAY] Re: has struts reached the saturation

2006-03-19 Thread Dakota Jack
On 3/19/06, Mark Lowe <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> wrote: > On 3/19/06, Dakota Jack <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> wrote: > > > Frequently we find developers coding away to make something in Struts fit > > what they need on the job rather than what Struts needs. > > Isn't that the point? So what does struts need acco

Re: [FRIDAY] Re: has struts reached the saturation

2006-03-19 Thread Dakota Jack
Here is a JSF big gun. At least now we know what this surprising new committer who seems to know nothing about Struts does; he reads motivational books. On 3/19/06, Gary VanMatre <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> wrote: > >From: "Alexandre Poitras" <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> > > > > You keep saying Tapesty "does what

Re: [FRIDAY] Re: has struts reached the saturation

2006-03-19 Thread Dakota Jack
Well, since this is your preferred mode, lead the way. I will follow. I felt that this was pretty safe, but if you have some contrary opinions, please roll them out and I will be more than happy to address your concerns. If you don't have anything specific, then I am not interested. On 3/19/06,

Re: Developing and running Struts on Tomcat without an Internet Connection

2006-03-19 Thread Hey Nony Moose
Sounds like Gurpreet.S.Dhanoa is decribing the same shotgun apporach that I was saying I used (making local copies of referenced files), which I've always been sure was suboptimal but it got me out of trouble. (ie: it "works") I'll try to take in the comments given of how to fix it optimally for ne

Re: [FRIDAY] Re: has struts reached the saturation

2006-03-19 Thread Mark Lowe
On 3/19/06, Dakota Jack <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> wrote: > I really do see these fallacies coming up at all. The fallacies which > typically come up are ones like: (1) argument ad hominem; (2) appeal to > authority; (3) appeal to common practice; (4) appeal to emotion; (5) appeal > to flattery; (6) appl

Re: [FRIDAY] Re: has struts reached the saturation

2006-03-19 Thread Alexandre Poitras
Hey that's look like a very good book Gary. I was looking for something new to read so maybe I'll give it a try. Thank :) On 3/19/06, Gary VanMatre <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> wrote: > >From: "Alexandre Poitras" <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> > > > > You keep saying Tapesty "does what JSF wants to do better than JSF

Re: [FRIDAY] Re: has struts reached the saturation

2006-03-19 Thread Gary VanMatre
>From: "Alexandre Poitras" <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> > > You keep saying Tapesty "does what JSF wants to do better than JSF > does it". I have looked into the two from a technical point of view > and I prefered JSF. How about giving some technical arguments for once > since you are complaing about lo

ot: cool os projects

2006-03-19 Thread netsql
http://www.wilsonresearch.com/2006/ostgawards06/ostgawards4.php .V - To unsubscribe, e-mail: [EMAIL PROTECTED] For additional commands, e-mail: [EMAIL PROTECTED]

Re: [FRIDAY] Re: has struts reached the saturation

2006-03-19 Thread Alexandre Poitras
You keep saying Tapesty "does what JSF wants to do better than JSF does it". I have looked into the two from a technical point of view and I prefered JSF. How about giving some technical arguments for once since you are complaing about logic fallacies? Is it because it isn't a standard? On 3/19/06

Monty Python

2006-03-19 Thread Dakota Jack
Since this is Friday: How about a little Monty Python *Receptionist:* Yes, sir? *Man:* I'd like to have an argument please. *Receptionist:* Certainly, sir, have you been here before...? *Man:* No, this is my first time. *Receptionist:* I see. Do you want to have the full argument, or were you

Re: [FRIDAY] Re: has struts reached the saturation

2006-03-19 Thread Dakota Jack
I really do see these fallacies coming up at all. The fallacies which typically come up are ones like: (1) argument ad hominem; (2) appeal to authority; (3) appeal to common practice; (4) appeal to emotion; (5) appeal to flattery; (6) appleal to popularity; (7) appeal to riducle; (8) biased sample

Re: [FRIDAY] Re: has struts reached the saturation

2006-03-19 Thread Mark Lowe
On 3/19/06, Dakota Jack <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> wrote: > Indeed! Hoo hah! Has anyone asked why Tapestry, which is just JSF done > well in my opinion, is causing no difficulties on the Struts list? Diveristy is important, even those who don't agree with a darwinian model seem to agree with this. Tryi

Re: Struts CMS ?

2006-03-19 Thread netsql
http://sourceforge.net/projects/infonoia .V On 3/18/06, Shshank Jain <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> wrote: Hii, Are there any Content management systems (CMS) which can be easily integrated into Struts based systems ? Presently trying to get things working with lenya. -Shanky --