Re: Hive Vs Pig: Master's thesis

2014-05-03 Thread Sarfraz Ramay
thanks for the explanation and good suggestions. Regards, Sarfraz Rasheed Ramay (DIT) Dublin, Ireland. On Sat, May 3, 2014 at 6:56 PM, Edward Capriolo wrote: > > These days pig and hive are designed to play together more, it is not a VS > thing. Benchmarks I barely read them any more. They are

Re: Hive Vs Pig: Master's thesis

2014-05-03 Thread Edward Capriolo
These days pig and hive are designed to play together more, it is not a VS thing. Benchmarks I barely read them any more. They are typically done by a few types of entities: 1) vendors that clearly have something to gain by presenting one side of the issue 2) people not familiar with the intricacie

Re: Hive Vs Pig: Master's thesis

2014-05-03 Thread Sarfraz Ramay
Thanks for the suggestion. Can you please explain a little on "focusing on the design, the implementation with third party tools", do you mean comparing them ? And by script you mean scripts of UDFs, SerDes and Loaders ? Regards, Sarfraz Rasheed Ramay (DIT) Dublin, Ireland. On Sat, May 3, 201

Re: Hive Vs Pig: Master's thesis

2014-05-03 Thread Edward Capriolo
IMHP Comparing the "performance" is boring and has been done umpteen times before. The world won't get much out of another performance benchmark, other then a bunch of fan boys saying "Look ours is faster hahahahah" and then the other side says "but in this case ours is faster and that is the more

Re: Hive Vs Pig: Master's thesis

2014-05-03 Thread Sarfraz Ramay
Thanks Thejas for your input! These are interesting and very specific which is exactly what is required for a masters thesis. Are there any publications on Hive and the evaluation of its performance that i can use to compare ? Regards, Sarfraz Rasheed Ramay (DIT) Dublin, Ireland. On Sat, May 3,

Re: Hive Vs Pig: Master's thesis

2014-05-02 Thread Thejas Nair
The primary difference between hive and pig is the language. There are implementation differences that will result in performance differences, but it will be hard to figure out what aspect of implementation responsible for what improvement. I think a more interesting project would be to compare th

Re: Hive Vs Pig: Master's thesis

2014-05-01 Thread Sarfraz Ramay
> > > Hi, > > It seems that both Hive and Pig are used for managing large data sets. > Hive is more SQL oriented whereas Pig is more for the data flows. I am > doing a master's thesis on the performance evaluation of both. Can some > please provide a list of tasks that would make for an interesting