Re: Job Manager minimum memory hard coded to 768

2017-09-30 Thread Haohui Mai
We have observed the same issue in our production cluster. Filed FLINK-7743 for the fix. ~Haohui On Fri, Sep 29, 2017 at 1:18 AM Till Rohrmann wrote: > Hi Dan, > > I think Aljoscha is right and the 768 MB minimum JM memory is more of a > legacy artifact which was never properly refactored. If I

Re: Job Manager minimum memory hard coded to 768

2017-09-29 Thread Till Rohrmann
Hi Dan, I think Aljoscha is right and the 768 MB minimum JM memory is more of a legacy artifact which was never properly refactored. If I remember correctly, then we had problems when starting Flink in a container with a lower memory limit. Therefore this limit was introduced. But I'm actually not

Re: Job Manager minimum memory hard coded to 768

2017-09-28 Thread Aljoscha Krettek
I believe this could be from a time when there was not yet the setting "containerized.heap-cutoff-min" since this part of the code is quite old. I think we could be able to remove that restriction but I'm not sure so I'm cc'ing Till who knows those parts best. @Till, what do you think? > On 28

Job Manager minimum memory hard coded to 768

2017-09-28 Thread Dan Circelli
In our usage of Flink, our Yarn Job Manager never goes above ~48 MB of heap utilization. In order to maximize the heap available to the Task Managers I thought we could shrink our Job Manager heap setting down from the 1024MB we were using to something tiny like 128MB. However, doing so results