Re: Quorom consistency in a changing ring

2010-04-26 Thread Benjamin Black
Live nodes that have tokens indicating they should receive a copy of data count towards write quorum. This means if a node is down (not decommissioned) the copy sent to the node acting as the hinted handoff replica will not count towards achieving quorum. If a token is moved, it is moved. It is

Re: Quorom consistency in a changing ring

2010-04-26 Thread Peter Schüller
> Increasing the replication level is known to break it. Thanks! Yes, of that I am aware. When I said ring changes I meant nodes being added and removed, or just re-balanced, implying tokens moving around the ring. -- / Peter Schuller aka scode

Re: Quorom consistency in a changing ring

2010-04-26 Thread David Timothy Strauss
Increasing the replication level is known to break it. --Original Message-- From: Peter Schuller Sender: sc...@scode.org To: user@cassandra.apache.org ReplyTo: user@cassandra.apache.org Subject: Quorom consistency in a changing ring Sent: Apr 26, 2010 21:55 Hello, Is my interpretation

Quorom consistency in a changing ring

2010-04-26 Thread Peter Schuller
Hello, Is my interpretation correct that Cassandra is intended to guarantee quorom consistency (overlapping read/write sets) at all times, including a ring that is actively changing? I.e., there are no (intended) cases where qurom consistency is defeated due to writes or reads going to nodes that