Re: [Usability] Image Viewing vs. Editing

2008-01-17 Thread Calum Benson
On 19 Dec 2007, at 12:01, Matthew Thomas wrote: > This is an excellent point, but it doesn't apply just to images. It > also applies at least to HTML files (e.g. Nvu vs. Epiphany) and to > vector drawings (e.g. Inkscape vs. EOG). > > So it might be worth considering a UI that can work across

Re: [Usability] Image Viewing vs. Editing

2007-12-19 Thread Jacob Beauregard
What I'm saying is that there are different ways to work with image files, like edit, and manage/view., and that default applications, as a design constraint, can't choose which one you want to do around half of the time (if editing and viewing have similar weights). Editing has a larger cost t

Re: [Usability] Image Viewing vs. Editing

2007-12-19 Thread Carlos Moreno
Kovacs Baldvin wrote: >> However, what about this scenario: have an "open in default image >> editor" button in the image viewer. > > Interesting that "less" for example has this, and is extremely > comfortable. If you press "v" while viewing a file, it opens in an > editor Interesting that when o

Re: [Usability] Image Viewing vs. Editing

2007-12-19 Thread Matthew Thomas
Jacob Beauregard wrote: >... > I have an idea. It seems that there's a battle > between image viewing and editing for default > application's file association between different > users. Some users use mostly image editing, while > some users mostly just want to view files. However, > there are more

Re: [Usability] Image Viewing vs. Editing

2007-12-19 Thread Denis Washington
On Wed, 2007-12-19 at 00:14 -0500, Jacob Beauregard wrote: > However, what about this scenario: have an "open in default image > editor" button in the image viewer. eog (GNOME's default image viewer) has an "Open With" menu item in the "File" menu with a sub-menu to choose the appropiate app, muc

Re: [Usability] Image Viewing vs. Editing

2007-12-19 Thread Kovacs Baldvin
> However, what about this scenario: have an "open in default image > editor" button in the image viewer. Interesting that "less" for example has this, and is extremely comfortable. If you press "v" while viewing a file, it opens in an editor, positioned to the same place where the viewer was. Ba

[Usability] Image Viewing vs. Editing

2007-12-18 Thread Jacob Beauregard
I have an idea. It seems that there's a battle between image viewing and editing for default application's file association between different users. Some users use mostly image editing, while some users mostly just want to view files. However, there are more users in the general middle ground that