Re: [Bug 756317] Re: Captive portals may corrupt apt package lists

2014-03-20 Thread Bryan
I'm not sure why I couldn't convince the security team that this is a security issue. The ability for an attacker to write arbitrary information to your software update database sounds like a pretty darn big security flaw. Bryan Harris, PE Research Engineer Structures and Materials Evaluation Gro

Re: [Bug 756317] Re: Captive portals may corrupt apt package lists

2014-03-20 Thread Bryan
Even ignoring that fact that this is a huge security issue, a computer connecting to free wifi at Starbucks should not irreversibly corrupt the update process requiring manual intervention. Bryan Harris, PE Research Engineer Structures and Materials Evaluation Group University of Dayton Research I

Re: [Bug 756317] Re: Captive portals may corrupt apt package lists

2014-03-20 Thread Bryan
Yes, this bug is a PITA. I can't see why something as important as an update list isn't cryptographically verified. Heck, even a quick md5sum check would catch this 99.9% of the time. Bryan Harris, PE Research Engineer Structures and Materials Evaluation Group University of Dayton Research I