Re: [Bug 49217] Re: Problem in FSCK checking Chinese filename (Big5)

2008-04-16 Thread Onno Benschop
When you ran chkdsk you were running DOS or Windows. This means that a code-page is set for the operating system at that time. When you insert a USB disk, it is also running under that code-page. When you then run chkdsk it checks characters based on the current code-page. It has just occurred to

Re: [Bug 49217] Re: Problem in FSCK checking Chinese filename (Big5)

2008-04-16 Thread Onno Benschop
The chkdsk command is running with a specified code-page because it's running within DOS or Windows. I strongly suspect that you'll find that if you change the code-page, all kinds of nasty things will happen. Again, if you can provide an actual specification that indicates that these characters a

Re: [Bug 49217] Re: Problem in FSCK checking Chinese filename (Big5)

2008-04-16 Thread Onno Benschop
I don't doubt that you can use a bad character in a Linux implementation. Also, the vfat module and dosfsck are not the same piece of software and both read from the drive in completely different ways. My point is that dosfsck is checking a FAT file system. The problem is not that these characters

Re: [Bug 49217] Re: Problem in FSCK checking Chinese filename (Big5)

2008-04-15 Thread Onno Benschop
Uhm, both these characters, '\' and '|' *are* bad characters as a non-Chinese (Big5) FAT filename AFAIK. If you have a reference that says otherwise, let me know and I'll have a look at it. -- Problem in FSCK checking Chinese filename (Big5) https://bugs.launchpad.net/bugs/49217 You received thi

Re: [Bug 49217] Re: Problem in FSCK checking Chinese filename (Big5)

2008-03-18 Thread Onno Benschop
Determining the code page number has been the largest issue. It is as far as I've been able to investigate not detectable on the file-system itself, which means that the end user is expected to supply it. That really doesn't work. Whilst investigating this I toyed with the idea of reading the conf

Re: [Bug 49217] Re: Problem in FSCK checking Chinese filename (Big5)

2007-05-27 Thread Onno Benschop
Hi, just got your message. I'm currently away from my computer but I'm still working on this. I expect to do some more when I return next week. Would you be able to test versions if I release them? Or could you create a tiny FAT file system that shows the problem so I can test stuff as I'm fixing i