[Bug 68589] Re: Failed file system check, weird behaviour

2008-05-06 Thread Aaron
I'm just giving ideas, I like simplicity too and certainly not demand additional ways to do one thing. For me your fix is just not ultimate option - not running fsck at all or mounting drive manually does add burden on end user that probably doesn't want to know what fsck is or use any special tric

[Bug 68589] Re: Failed file system check, weird behaviour

2008-05-06 Thread Theodore Ts'o
I gave a solution. In my first reply: If a particular filesystem is not always present, then you should configure the disk so that the fsck pass number is 0, and that mount option "noauto" is present so that the filesystem is not mounted at boot time. Then it will not interrupt the boot process,

[Bug 68589] Re: Failed file system check, weird behaviour

2008-05-06 Thread Aaron
This is still present in 8.04 and there seems no good way to fix this now in ubuntu - you don't like the ignore approach, but you don't provide any other means to fix it properly. Disabling fsck completely is bad, giving user power to mount file systems is not bad, but it requires additional action

[Bug 68589] Re: Failed file system check, weird behaviour

2007-06-20 Thread Scott James Remnant
Nothing Upstart-related in this bug report ** Changed in: upstart (Ubuntu) Status: Unconfirmed => Rejected -- Failed file system check, weird behaviour https://bugs.launchpad.net/bugs/68589 You received this bug notification because you are a member of Ubuntu Bugs, which is the bug contac

[Bug 68589] Re: Failed file system check, weird behaviour

2007-06-19 Thread Theodore Ts'o
Well, the problem is that we need to distinguish between a critical filesystem (like /usr) being not present, and something completely optional, like /media/disk. More of a concern is where a filesystem is critical for an application-level server, and if it's missing it causes the server to reall

[Bug 68589] Re: Failed file system check, weird behaviour

2007-06-19 Thread finalbeta
I would like to mention that from an end users perspective, they way you tell me I should edit fstab is not good. Ubuntu should be able to handle futile things like this, it should detect the partition is not present and continue booting. "Fail with grace, not fall down on it's face" -- Failed

[Bug 68589] Re: Failed file system check, weird behaviour

2007-06-19 Thread finalbeta
It was Edgy at the time of posting, now It's Feisty. But the rack is gone. We might as well close this. Nothing will happen to it. In any case, the mount all file system spec should have solved this. (but didn't). -- Failed file system check, weird behaviour https://bugs.launchpad.net/bugs/68589

[Bug 68589] Re: Failed file system check, weird behaviour

2007-06-19 Thread Theodore Ts'o
What version of Ubuntu is this? If a particular filesystem is not always present, then you should configure the disk so that the fsck pass number is 0, and that mount option "noauto" is present so that the filesystem is not mounted at boot time. Then it will not interrupt the boot process, and t

[Bug 68589] Re: Failed file system check, weird behaviour

2006-11-12 Thread towsonu2003
** Changed in: Ubuntu Sourcepackagename: None => e2fsprogs -- Failed file system check, weird behaviour https://launchpad.net/bugs/68589 -- ubuntu-bugs mailing list ubuntu-bugs@lists.ubuntu.com https://lists.ubuntu.com/mailman/listinfo/ubuntu-bugs