Re: [Bug 246053] Re: pm-utils doesn't detect uswsusp in hardy

2008-09-22 Thread hyperair
-BEGIN PGP SIGNED MESSAGE- Hash: SHA1 We should also not forget that pm-utils's default hibernate takes a long time to suspend to disk and to resume. s2disk is considerably faster at this. I've timed something like >60s time taken consistently to resume, and s2disk taking ~20s. Even boo

[Bug 246053] Re: pm-utils doesn't detect uswsusp in hardy

2008-09-22 Thread Benoit Grégoire
It was in the original bg report (I am the original reporter of this bug and solution), but somebody redacted it out. It's the Macbook pro core 2 duo. I think that more than qualifies as "Recent hardware" (not to mention pretty mainstream). Without this fix, it wont hibernate at all. -- pm-uti

Re: [Bug 246053] Re: pm-utils doesn't detect uswsusp in hardy

2008-09-22 Thread Steve Langasek
> If that's the case, are you saying that pm-utils should be left in its > current, broken state? While uswsusp might break for people who already > have installed it, mistakenly, there are cases where people cannot > hibernate without using uswsusp (and hence applying some workaround > listed abov

[Bug 246053] Re: pm-utils doesn't detect uswsusp in hardy

2008-09-04 Thread hyperair
** Description changed: Binary package hint: pm-utils - pm-utils does not detect the presence of uswsusp (it looks for s2disk in - /usr/sbin instead of /sbin), resulting in Suspend and Hibernate using - pm-utils's default method. For some users (those whose systems cannot - suspend/hibernate

Re: [Bug 246053] Re: pm-utils doesn't detect uswsusp in hardy

2008-09-04 Thread hyperair
-BEGIN PGP SIGNED MESSAGE- Hash: SHA1 I just realized that it's not just s2disk affected, but s2ram and s2both as well. So I've created a more up to date debdiff, and a corresponding build log, which I've attached. - -- Hyperair -BEGIN PGP SIGNATURE- Version: GnuPG v1.4.6 (GNU/Li

Re: [Bug 246053] Re: pm-utils doesn't detect uswsusp in hardy

2008-09-04 Thread hyperair
-BEGIN PGP SIGNED MESSAGE- Hash: SHA1 Martin Pitt wrote: > hyperair [2008-09-04 0:50 -]: >> Another thing is that if this issue is left as it is, and users for >> whom uswsusp is broken upgrade to Intrepid, where there's a new >> version of pm-utils which correctly utilizes uswsusp, t

Re: [Bug 246053] Re: pm-utils doesn't detect uswsusp in hardy

2008-09-03 Thread Martin Pitt
hyperair [2008-09-04 0:50 -]: > Another thing is that if this issue is left as it is, and users for > whom uswsusp is broken upgrade to Intrepid, where there's a new > version of pm-utils which correctly utilizes uswsusp, then it's > going to get a whole lot of bug reports and/or complaints/ne

Re: [Bug 246053] Re: pm-utils doesn't detect uswsusp in hardy

2008-09-03 Thread hyperair
-BEGIN PGP SIGNED MESSAGE- Hash: SHA1 Steve Langasek wrote: > I've updated the bug description to make it clear that there *is* > regression potential here. Indeed, the regression potential may be very > broad, and is difficult to quantify at all, precisely because such a bug > would have

[Bug 246053] Re: pm-utils doesn't detect uswsusp in hardy

2008-09-03 Thread Steve Langasek
I've updated the bug description to make it clear that there *is* regression potential here. Indeed, the regression potential may be very broad, and is difficult to quantify at all, precisely because such a bug would have prevented testing in hardy (or, it appears, in gutsy) to confirm that uswsus

[Bug 246053] Re: pm-utils doesn't detect uswsusp in hardy

2008-09-03 Thread Steve Langasek
** Description changed: Binary package hint: pm-utils pm-utils does not detect the presence of uswsusp (it looks for s2disk in /usr/sbin instead of /sbin), resulting in Suspend and Hibernate using pm-utils's default method. For some users (those whose systems cannot suspend/hibernate

[Bug 246053] Re: pm-utils doesn't detect uswsusp in hardy

2008-09-03 Thread hyperair
Might I point out that you're kind of late saying that? According to the timestamps, the error had already been fixed some 18 hours before that post. This kind of redundancy is unnecessary, unwanted, and hence, effectively spam. -- pm-utils doesn't detect uswsusp in hardy https://bugs.launchpad.n

[Bug 246053] Re: pm-utils doesn't detect uswsusp in hardy

2008-09-02 Thread Sarah Hobbs
No, really, please *don't* assign a team such as ubuntu-core-dev to a bug. It contains many, many people, most who don't care at all about this package. Thus, it's effectively spam! -- pm-utils doesn't detect uswsusp in hardy https://bugs.launchpad.net/bugs/246053 You received this bug notific

[Bug 246053] Re: pm-utils doesn't detect uswsusp in hardy

2008-09-02 Thread hyperair
** Changed in: pm-utils (Ubuntu Hardy) Assignee: (unassigned) => Ubuntu Stable Release Updates Team (ubuntu-sru) ** Changed in: pm-utils (Ubuntu Hardy) Assignee: Ubuntu Stable Release Updates Team (ubuntu-sru) => hyperair (hyperair) ** Changed in: pm-utils (Ubuntu Hardy) Status:

[Bug 246053] Re: pm-utils doesn't detect uswsusp in hardy

2008-09-02 Thread hyperair
Updated debdiff to show bug number. ** Summary changed: - pm-utils doesn't detect uswsusp in hardy (with fix) + pm-utils doesn't detect uswsusp in hardy ** Description changed: Binary package hint: pm-utils - This prevents uswsusp from being used (except by calling s2disk - manually). The

[Bug 246053] Re: pm-utils doesn't detect uswsusp in hardy (with fix)

2008-09-02 Thread Martin Pitt
This is already fixed in the intrepid version, where the commands are searched in $PATH. If anyone wants to own the SRU for hardy, please go ahead (i. e. coordinate testing, etc.) ** Changed in: pm-utils (Ubuntu Intrepid) Assignee: Ubuntu Sponsors for main (ubuntu-main-sponsors) => (unassign

[Bug 246053] Re: pm-utils doesn't detect uswsusp in hardy (with fix)

2008-09-02 Thread hyperair
Assigning to ubuntu-main-sponsors as said by Scott Kitterman ** Changed in: pm-utils (Ubuntu) Assignee: (unassigned) => Ubuntu Sponsors for main (ubuntu-main-sponsors) -- pm-utils doesn't detect uswsusp in hardy (with fix) https://bugs.launchpad.net/bugs/246053 You received this bug notific

[Bug 246053] Re: pm-utils doesn't detect uswsusp in hardy (with fix)

2008-09-02 Thread Scott Kitterman
The appropriate action is to subscribe ubuntu-main-sponsors. ** Changed in: pm-utils (Ubuntu) Assignee: Ubuntu Core Development Team (ubuntu-core-dev) => (unassigned) -- pm-utils doesn't detect uswsusp in hardy (with fix) https://bugs.launchpad.net/bugs/246053 You received this bug notifica

[Bug 246053] Re: pm-utils doesn't detect uswsusp in hardy (with fix)

2008-09-02 Thread hyperair
Attaching build log ** Attachment added: "Build log for the new deb" http://launchpadlibrarian.net/17237757/pm-utils_0.99.2-3ubuntu11.log -- pm-utils doesn't detect uswsusp in hardy (with fix) https://bugs.launchpad.net/bugs/246053 You received this bug notification because you are a member o

[Bug 246053] Re: pm-utils doesn't detect uswsusp in hardy (with fix)

2008-09-02 Thread hyperair
Uh whoops. Forgot to attach it. ** Attachment added: "pm-utils_0.99.2-3ubuntu10_0.99.2-3ubuntu11.debdiff" http://launchpadlibrarian.net/17236715/pm-utils_0.99.2-3ubuntu10_0.99.2-3ubuntu11.debdiff -- pm-utils doesn't detect uswsusp in hardy (with fix) https://bugs.launchpad.net/bugs/246053 Yo

[Bug 246053] Re: pm-utils doesn't detect uswsusp in hardy (with fix)

2008-09-02 Thread hyperair
I'm assigning it to ubuntu-core-dev since it seems to be a packaging problem and the maintainer of the package is shown to be them. ** Changed in: pm-utils (Ubuntu) Assignee: (unassigned) => Ubuntu Core Development Team (ubuntu-core-dev) -- pm-utils doesn't detect uswsusp in hardy (with fix

[Bug 246053] Re: pm-utils doesn't detect uswsusp in hardy (with fix)

2008-09-02 Thread hyperair
The above workaround worked, and I've created a debdiff for a new package of pm-utils which will fix this issue (sets the default S2DISK_BIN to /sbin/s2disk. I'd appreciate it if someone could test it for me. Also, while my Lenovo Y410 can hibernate without the help of uswsusp, it takes a long tim

[Bug 246053] Re: pm-utils doesn't detect uswsusp in hardy (with fix)

2008-07-06 Thread Vladimir Osintsev
** Changed in: pm-utils (Ubuntu) Status: New => Confirmed -- pm-utils doesn't detect uswsusp in hardy (with fix) https://bugs.launchpad.net/bugs/246053 You received this bug notification because you are a member of Ubuntu Bugs, which is subscribed to Ubuntu. -- ubuntu-bugs mailing list u