[Bug 2100003] Re: backport mofed-modules-24.10 24.10.1.1.4.0-0ubuntu2

2025-06-20 Thread Andreas Hasenack
Changing the devel task's status to "Fix Released", since the package is there with this same version. mofed-modules-24.10 | 24.10.1.1.4.0-0ubuntu2~24.04.1 | noble/new/5302e34 | source mofed-modules-24.10 | 24.10.0.7.0.0+ds1-0ubuntu1~24.10.1 | oracular-updates/universe | source mofed

[Bug 2100003] Re: backport mofed-modules-24.10 24.10.1.1.4.0-0ubuntu2

2025-06-20 Thread Andreas Hasenack
** Description changed: [Impact] A new 24.10 minor version has been released from upstream, and should be - backported under the HWE exception. This also allow to backport various - fixes to the packaging. + backported under the HWE exception. This also allows us to backport + various fixes

[Bug 2100003] Re: backport mofed-modules-24.10 24.10.1.1.4.0-0ubuntu2

2025-05-21 Thread Mitchell Augustin
** Description changed: [Impact] A new 24.10 minor version has been released from upstream, and should be backported under the HWE exception. This also allow to backport various fixes to the packaging. It was tested using a Noble PPA because the real hardware is available in Nobl

[Bug 2100003] Re: backport mofed-modules-24.10 24.10.1.1.4.0-0ubuntu2

2025-05-21 Thread Agathe Porte
** Description changed: [Impact] A new 24.10 minor version has been released from upstream, and should be backported under the HWE exception. This also allow to backport various fixes to the packaging. It was tested using a Noble PPA because the real hardware is available in Nobl

[Bug 2100003] Re: backport mofed-modules-24.10 24.10.1.1.4.0-0ubuntu2

2025-05-21 Thread Timo Aaltonen
oracular will not be updated at this point ** Changed in: mofed-modules-24.10 (Ubuntu Oracular) Status: In Progress => Won't Fix -- You received this bug notification because you are a member of Ubuntu Bugs, which is subscribed to Ubuntu. https://bugs.launchpad.net/bugs/213 Title:

[Bug 2100003] Re: backport mofed-modules-24.10 24.10.1.1.4.0-0ubuntu2

2025-05-20 Thread Mitchell Augustin
** Description changed: [Impact] A new 24.10 minor version has been released from upstream, and should be backported under the HWE exception. This also allow to backport various fixes to the packaging. It was tested using a Noble PPA because the real hardware is available in Nobl

[Bug 2100003] Re: backport mofed-modules-24.10 24.10.1.1.4.0-0ubuntu2

2025-03-19 Thread Robie Basak
Next steps: I think the private test suite question is still hypothetical at the moment, since there are so many other open issues that currently sound like they invalidate this SRU. Please revise the analysis in this bug to cover all other issues, so that the only review point remaining is that a

[Bug 2100003] Re: backport mofed-modules-24.10 24.10.1.1.4.0-0ubuntu2

2025-03-19 Thread Robie Basak
PS. my previous comment is me reviewing this upload as an individual member of the SRU team. It is not an opinion of the entire SRU team or the Technical Board. -- You received this bug notification because you are a member of Ubuntu Bugs, which is subscribed to Ubuntu. https://bugs.launchpad.net

[Bug 2100003] Re: backport mofed-modules-24.10 24.10.1.1.4.0-0ubuntu2

2025-03-19 Thread Robie Basak
> as the mofed dkms is "hard" to test and can only be done in an LTS Why is this the case, please? -- You received this bug notification because you are a member of Ubuntu Bugs, which is subscribed to Ubuntu. https://bugs.launchpad.net/bugs/213 Title: backport mofed-modules-24.10 24.10.1.

[Bug 2100003] Re: backport mofed-modules-24.10 24.10.1.1.4.0-0ubuntu2

2025-03-19 Thread Robie Basak
> given that this also could qualify as an HWE upload as explained? On your "HWE exception" claims, let me be clear. If an SRU upload *contains* a hardware enablement as part of other changes, that does not automatically give the other changes a free pass. The other changes would require SRU justi

[Bug 2100003] Re: backport mofed-modules-24.10 24.10.1.1.4.0-0ubuntu2

2025-03-18 Thread Timo Aaltonen
I think requesting for a special case would fit this best, as the mofed dkms is "hard" to test and can only be done in an LTS, even though it needs to be backported to the interim releases too in order for the kernels from that release (which are backported to LTS as HWE) to be able to use the new

[Bug 2100003] Re: backport mofed-modules-24.10 24.10.1.1.4.0-0ubuntu2

2025-03-17 Thread Agathe Porte
Hello Robie, Do you agree that our private testing as described is enough for accepting this microrelease as an SRU ? If not, what are the next steps, given that this also could qualify as an HWE upload as explained ? Thanks. -- You received this bug notification because you are a member of Ub

[Bug 2100003] Re: backport mofed-modules-24.10 24.10.1.1.4.0-0ubuntu2

2025-03-05 Thread Agathe Porte
> No, those are two different exceptions. If you're doing hardware enablement, then this bug should be titled something like "hardware X not supported", and then the impact to users would be self-evident. If you're fixing bugs, then https://documentation.ubuntu.com/sru/en/latest/reference/requireme

[Bug 2100003] Re: backport mofed-modules-24.10 24.10.1.1.4.0-0ubuntu2

2025-03-04 Thread Robie Basak
> A new 24.10 minor version has been released from upstream, and should be backported under the HWE exception. No, those are two different exceptions. If you're doing hardware enablement, then this bug should be titled something like "hardware X not supported", and then the impact to users would b

[Bug 2100003] Re: backport mofed-modules-24.10 24.10.1.1.4.0-0ubuntu2

2025-03-04 Thread Robie Basak
> If you're fixing bugs If you're fixing bugs by choosing to take a new upstream bugfix release, that is, rather than cherry-picking, then https://documentation.ubuntu.com/sru/en/latest/reference/requirements/#new- upstream-microreleases applies, and you should document how it is that upstream mee

[Bug 2100003] Re: backport mofed-modules-24.10 24.10.1.1.4.0-0ubuntu2

2025-03-04 Thread Agathe Porte
** Description changed: [Impact] A new 24.10 minor version has been released from upstream, and should be backported under the HWE exception. This also allow to backport various fixes to the packaging. + It was tested using a Noble PPA because the real hardware is available + in Nobl

[Bug 2100003] Re: backport mofed-modules-24.10 24.10.1.1.4.0-0ubuntu2

2025-02-25 Thread Agathe Porte
** Changed in: mofed-modules-24.10 (Ubuntu Oracular) Status: New => In Progress -- You received this bug notification because you are a member of Ubuntu Bugs, which is subscribed to Ubuntu. https://bugs.launchpad.net/bugs/213 Title: backport mofed-modules-24.10 24.10.1.1.4.0-0ubuntu