[Bug 1179774] Re: ipmi kernel modules not detecting OCPv3 AMD Roadrunner BMC

2016-07-26 Thread Stefan Bader
Setting this to fix released but I do not know for sure. Sounds like it was and this was back in Trusty, so I assume there would have been updates if this did not get out. ** Changed in: linux (Ubuntu) Status: Fix Committed => Fix Released ** Changed in: linux (Ubuntu) Assignee: Stefa

[Bug 1179774] Re: ipmi kernel modules not detecting OCPv3 AMD Roadrunner BMC

2013-10-09 Thread David Duffey
** Changed in: opencompute Status: New => Fix Released -- You received this bug notification because you are a member of Ubuntu Bugs, which is subscribed to Ubuntu. https://bugs.launchpad.net/bugs/1179774 Title: ipmi kernel modules not detecting OCPv3 AMD Roadrunner BMC To manage notif

[Bug 1179774] Re: ipmi kernel modules not detecting OCPv3 AMD Roadrunner BMC

2013-08-08 Thread David Duffey
So after some testing what I found was that after installing ipmitool a reboot was required, after the reboot the ipmi_devintf module was loaded. When doing a first boot, only ipmi_si and ipmi_msghandler is loaded... installing ipmitool complains that /dev/ipmi* doesn't exist. After rebooting the

[Bug 1179774] Re: ipmi kernel modules not detecting OCPv3 AMD Roadrunner BMC

2013-08-08 Thread David Duffey
** Changed in: opencompute Assignee: (unassigned) => David Duffey (david-duffey) -- You received this bug notification because you are a member of Ubuntu Bugs, which is subscribed to Ubuntu. https://bugs.launchpad.net/bugs/1179774 Title: ipmi kernel modules not detecting OCPv3 AMD Roadrun

[Bug 1179774] Re: ipmi kernel modules not detecting OCPv3 AMD Roadrunner BMC

2013-08-08 Thread David Duffey
I tried the precise daily build (08-Aug-2013) which had the kernel 3.8.0-27-generic #40 for the installer... then after I rebooted 3.8.0-28-generic #41 was installed. uname -a suggests the installer kernel was built/compiled on Fri Jul 19th? Anyway, the BMC did not work (ipmitool lan print). I

Re: [Bug 1179774] Re: ipmi kernel modules not detecting OCPv3 AMD Roadrunner BMC

2013-07-15 Thread Stefan Bader
If you could make sure which part of dmesg info related to the ipmi modules is there before manual probing (well essentially right after boot as this should be automatic). And maybe you could check which ipmi modules are loaded then. And maybe compare whether there is any difference after manual pr

Re: [Bug 1179774] Re: ipmi kernel modules not detecting OCPv3 AMD Roadrunner BMC

2013-07-15 Thread David Duffey
I would tend to agree as well, but the ipmi devices are not created if I simply boot or reload the module and things like "ipmitool lan print" do not work (until I run the script to initialize). I can do some more poking around if you give ideas. David -- You received this bug notification beca

[Bug 1179774] Re: ipmi kernel modules not detecting OCPv3 AMD Roadrunner BMC

2013-07-15 Thread Stefan Bader
Comment #15 would mean to me that it _was_ discovered. The regspacing and address of the pci discovery looks identical to the working case and the last line says the module was initialized. -- You received this bug notification because you are a member of Ubuntu Bugs, which is subscribed to Ubunt

[Bug 1179774] Re: ipmi kernel modules not detecting OCPv3 AMD Roadrunner BMC

2013-07-12 Thread David Duffey
I've tested stock raring (3.8.0-19) and proposed (3.8.0-27-40) and the ipmi interface doesn't work as I expected it to. I would like to see this support included in 12.04.3 LTS. Here is the relevant information from inserting the ipmi_si module: Jul 12 17:04:45 ubuntu kernel: [ 16.947988] ipmi

[Bug 1179774] Re: ipmi kernel modules not detecting OCPv3 AMD Roadrunner BMC

2013-07-12 Thread David Duffey
If I use the script to manually load the ipmi driver (from comment #1) the ipmi device works. -- You received this bug notification because you are a member of Ubuntu Bugs, which is subscribed to Ubuntu. https://bugs.launchpad.net/bugs/1179774 Title: ipmi kernel modules not detecting OCPv3 AMD

[Bug 1179774] Re: ipmi kernel modules not detecting OCPv3 AMD Roadrunner BMC

2013-06-28 Thread Stefan Bader
1. Not necessarily for the sake of the ipmi support only. If it works with the raring kernel it will work when the raring kernel becomes the 12.04.3 kernel. But I guess it make sense to get back to that as part of an overall integration test. So when we have a fix for 2. and think that kernel has

[Bug 1179774] Re: ipmi kernel modules not detecting OCPv3 AMD Roadrunner BMC

2013-06-28 Thread David Duffey
As long as it lands in the 12.04.3 LTS point release (August?), that is okay, no need to backport. I have two questions though. 1. I don't think I've tested this on stock raring. Should I test on stock raring or on a daily 12.04.3 build to make sure this will land in 12.04.3? 2. Could you also

[Bug 1179774] Re: ipmi kernel modules not detecting OCPv3 AMD Roadrunner BMC

2013-06-28 Thread Stefan Bader
Probably should have stated that more explicit in previous comment. Is there need for a backport into pre-3.7 kernels? Raring/13.04 should be ok as it is 3.8. -- You received this bug notification because you are a member of Ubuntu Bugs, which is subscribed to Ubuntu. https://bugs.launchpad.net/b

[Bug 1179774] Re: ipmi kernel modules not detecting OCPv3 AMD Roadrunner BMC

2013-06-26 Thread Stefan Bader
Ah ok, so it seems the basic support was already in for quite some time. I am not remembering which kernel version was used in the failing case but there seems to have been a change upstream about v3.7-rc2 which allows detecting a different regspacing and the working output seems to have detected a

[Bug 1179774] Re: ipmi kernel modules not detecting OCPv3 AMD Roadrunner BMC

2013-06-25 Thread David Duffey
Also here is the output of the ipmi_si module being loaded with the stock kernel (failed) and the leann kernel (works) failed: Jun 25 09:38:42 precise2 kernel: [ 186.940809] IPMI System Interface driver. Jun 25 09:38:42 precise2 kernel: [ 186.940857] ipmi_si :02:00.6: probing via PCI Jun 2

[Bug 1179774] Re: ipmi kernel modules not detecting OCPv3 AMD Roadrunner BMC

2013-06-25 Thread David Duffey
@ Stefan, brainfart on my side and missed the correct commands... here is the correct output of lspci -vvvnn. Also note this is running on the working kernel from comment #8, if that matters. 02:00.6 IPMI SMIC interface [0c07]: Broadcom Corporation Device [14e4:16b9] (prog-if 01) Subsyst

[Bug 1179774] Re: ipmi kernel modules not detecting OCPv3 AMD Roadrunner BMC

2013-06-25 Thread David Duffey
When testing a related bug for the tg3 driver (https://bugs.launchpad.net/opencompute/+bug/1178899) using this kernel (http://people.canonical.com/~ogasawara/lp1178899/) the ipmi_si module successfully worked. -- You received this bug notification because you are a member of Ubuntu Bugs, which is

Re: [Bug 1179774] Re: ipmi kernel modules not detecting OCPv3 AMD Roadrunner BMC

2013-06-25 Thread Stefan Bader
On 25.06.2013 18:32, David Duffey wrote: > Here is the output of lspci - on that device. Notice the address > change... I'm guessing this may be because I removed an add-on PCI card > in the process. > > > 01:00.6 IPMI SMIC interface: Broadcom Corporation Device 16b9 (prog-if 01) > Sub

[Bug 1179774] Re: ipmi kernel modules not detecting OCPv3 AMD Roadrunner BMC

2013-06-25 Thread David Duffey
Here is the output of lspci - on that device. Notice the address change... I'm guessing this may be because I removed an add-on PCI card in the process. 01:00.6 IPMI SMIC interface: Broadcom Corporation Device 16b9 (prog-if 01) Subsystem: Broadcom Corporation Device 96b9 Cont

[Bug 1179774] Re: ipmi kernel modules not detecting OCPv3 AMD Roadrunner BMC

2013-05-23 Thread Stefan Bader
David, could you add (or replace above output) the output of "lspci -vvvnn -s 02:00.6" so we can see all the id numbers. It seems the ipmi part can be done by adding a pci id to the ipmi_si driver. Are we aware of anybody else being on this already? ** Also affects: linux (Ubuntu) Importance: U