Re: [tor-talk] Hidden vs Clearnet Services

2013-01-29 Thread Raynardine
On 1/29/2013 5:55 PM, Katya Titov wrote: > Katya Titov : > > Thanks all for the information, and sorry for the double post. To > summarise, I see that the issues can be grouped into three areas: > privacy, political and technology. > The privacy side is about selecting what you require. This inc

Re: [tor-talk] Hidden vs Clearnet Services

2013-01-29 Thread Katya Titov
Katya Titov : > Raynardine : > > > I do not like connecting to clearnet services from Tor. > > > > I am not alone in this. > > > > There are arguments about the reasons why Tor hidden services can be > > better than clearnet services for users as well, but that would > > derail this thread. >

Re: [tor-talk] Hidden vs Clearnet Services

2013-01-29 Thread Raynardine
Thank you. To elaborate on those points: 1) Encrypted end-to-end (or "Tor" to "Tor") The end to end encryption (AKA "E2E") is one of the most important design aspects that could possibly exist. 2) Therefore not dependent on SSL SSL/TLS would be fine it they did not rely on Certificate Auth

Re: [tor-talk] Hidden vs Clearnet Services

2013-01-29 Thread adrelanos
>From point of view of hosting a hidden service, which is not hosted by anonymous people and which may alternatively also provide a clearnet domain. Positive aspects for hidden services over clearnet: 1) encrypted end-to-end (or "Tor" to "Tor") 2) therefore not dependent on SSL 3) hidden servic

Re: [tor-talk] Hidden vs Clearnet Services

2013-01-29 Thread Raynardine
On 1/29/2013 9:20 AM, k e bera wrote: > In the clearnet case, operators are accountable for their public promises and > by established norms and legalities of internet behaviour. What accountability? You mean the nice kind policemen in their blue shirts and shiny Justice-delivering guns? Sure,

Re: [tor-talk] Hidden vs Clearnet Services

2013-01-29 Thread k e bera
Both hidden and clearnet services can gather information to build profiles of their users over time, and try to correlate it with information from other services. What is stopping the operators from exploiting that information contrary to interests of the users? In the clearnet case, operators

Re: [tor-talk] Hidden vs Clearnet Services

2013-01-29 Thread Raynardine
On 1/29/2013 6:48 AM, Katya Titov wrote: > Raynardine : > >> I do not like connecting to clearnet services from Tor. >> >> I am not alone in this. >> >> There are arguments about the reasons why Tor hidden services can be >> better than clearnet services for users as well, but that would derail >>

Re: [tor-talk] Hidden vs Clearnet Services

2013-01-29 Thread Raynardine
On 1/29/2013 6:39 AM, Katya Titov wrote: > Raynardine : > >> I do not like connecting to clearnet services from Tor. >> >> I am not alone in this. >> >> There are arguments about the reasons why Tor hidden services can be >> better than clearnet services for users as well, but that would derail >>