Re: [VOTE] commit new Tomcat 4 SecurityManager XML Policy code toCVS

2002-09-24 Thread Glenn Nielsen
Costin, This is getting off topic from my original request. (And I am partly responsible ;-) My proposal is for adding thr XML policy code to the current existing Tomcat 4 HEAD branch. I would like to commit the code to CVS. Building Tomcat with this support is optional and can be left out of

Re: [VOTE] commit new Tomcat 4 SecurityManager XML Policy code toCVS

2002-09-24 Thread Glenn Nielsen
Costin Manolache wrote: > Glenn, > > As a new feature, you need a majority of votes and at least 3 +1. > My vote is -1 ( but is not a veto ). Only commits can be vetoed, > and I'll probably do so if castor is used - all tomcat is using > digester style for xml processing, and we have a proposal t

Re: [VOTE] commit new Tomcat 4 SecurityManager XML Policy code toCVS

2002-09-24 Thread Glenn Nielsen
Jean-Francois Arcand wrote: > > > Glenn Nielsen wrote: > >> The JVM itself anticipated a need for alternative application specific >> Policy >> implementations and has the hooks for doing it. >> >> Are you aware of anyone working on a new standard? Is there a JSR? > > > > [FYI] > JSR 115

Re: [VOTE] commit new Tomcat 4 SecurityManager XML Policy code toCVS

2002-09-24 Thread Jean-Francois Arcand
; Are you aware of anyone working on a new standard? Is there a JSR? [FYI] JSR 115 (http://jcp.org/aboutJava/communityprocess/first/jsr115/index.html) Java Authorization Contract for Container is in that direction (for expressing Web Permissions and for moving away from the *.policy file forma

Re: [VOTE] commit new Tomcat 4 SecurityManager XML Policy code toCVS

2002-09-24 Thread Glenn Nielsen
Remy Maucherat wrote: > Costin Manolache wrote: > >> Glenn Nielsen wrote: >> >> >>> >>> [ ] commit XML Policy source to jakarta-tomcat-4.0 HEAD >>> and include it in future release of Tomcat 4.1.x >>> [X] commit to CVS but don't add to the next release >>> [ ] create a Tomcat 4.2 dev

Re: [VOTE] commit new Tomcat 4 SecurityManager XML Policy code toCVS

2002-09-24 Thread Remy Maucherat
Costin Manolache wrote: > Glenn Nielsen wrote: > > >> >> [ ] commit XML Policy source to jakarta-tomcat-4.0 HEAD >> and include it in future release of Tomcat 4.1.x >> [X] commit to CVS but don't add to the next release >> [ ] create a Tomcat 4.2 development branch and commit there (

Re: [VOTE] commit new Tomcat 4 SecurityManager XML Policy code toCVS

2002-09-24 Thread Glenn Nielsen
Comments intermixed below. Costin Manolache wrote: > Glenn Nielsen wrote: > > >>Tomcat SecurityManager XML Policy configuration >>--- >> >>I have finished implementing support within Tomcat for using XML based >>security policy >>files. This was prop