[TLS]Re: I-D Action: draft-ietf-tls-hybrid-design-10.txt

2024-07-31 Thread Felix Günther
Hi Peter, We discussed this among the [DOWLING] authors; Douglas asked me to chime in here as he's offline the next couple of days. It is indeed true that the PRF-ODH assumption, as stated in [DOWLING] and https://ia.cr/2017/517, wouldn't be compatible when using the x-coordinate only, or wi

[TLS]Re: I-D Action: draft-ietf-tls-hybrid-design-10.txt

2024-07-31 Thread Marc Fischlin
Dear all, Douglas and the other "TLS co-authors" discussed this briefly, but I think that Douglas is offline for the next couple of days and asked me if I could answer on behalf of the authors. It is indeed true that the PRF-ODH assumption, as stated, wouldn't be comaptible with the usage of

[TLS]Re: Adoption call for Extended Key Update for TLS 1.3

2024-07-31 Thread Dan Wing
I also support adoption of this draft. I share David's observation that the client and server could simultaneously initiate an Extended Key Update, but I had a different mitigation in mind: each side chooses a random value and the higher value wins if there is another ExtendedKeyUpdate alread