Re: [TLS] New Version for draft-segers-tls-cert-validation-ext

2022-08-26 Thread Peter Gutmann
Ashley Kopman writes: >Although our use case is aviation, our goal is to write this draft so that it >can be used by other domains. Someone has to say this, so I may as well: I don't think you'll have to worry about anyone else using it. The PKIX WG left behind it a long trail of RFCs that no-o

Re: [TLS] New Version for draft-segers-tls-cert-validation-ext

2022-08-26 Thread Ashley Kopman
Peter, Thank you for taking the time to respond and for explaining the history behind this. You make some very valid points. I don’t believe we have sacrificed any functionality by making the extension generic enough to be used by others. It has been designed with the global civil aviation com

Re: [TLS] New Version for draft-segers-tls-cert-validation-ext

2022-08-26 Thread Rob Sayre
On Fri, Aug 26, 2022 at 8:09 AM Ashley Kopman wrote: > > With all of that said, I am here asking for guidance. I am new to this > community. I am not trying to game any bureaucratic processes. > I don't think anyone thinks you're doing anything wrong. I was just trying to explain why the process