Re: [TLS] Expanded alert codes

2018-05-21 Thread Peter Gutmann
Reviving this discussion, if I write up a draft for this what's going to happen to it? Will it get published, or shouted down? The reason I'm asking is that I've just spent the past three days debugging a TLS issue that's pretty much a poster child for why extended alerts are needed, it was somet

Re: [TLS] Expanded alert codes

2018-05-21 Thread Ion Larranaga Azcue
I would say it's unfair to expect other people to diagnose the problem by claiming "that information was all that was available" because you had access to: - traffic dumps of the failing handshakes - traffic dumps of working handshakes - the possibility to try any number of modifications of the

Re: [TLS] Expanded alert codes

2018-05-21 Thread Peter Gutmann
Ion Larranaga Azcue writes: >I would say it's unfair to expect other people to diagnose the problem by >claiming "that information was all that was available" because you had access >to: > >- traffic dumps of the failing handshakes There was no access to this. >- traffic dumps of working handsh