Re: [TLS] Asking for certificate authentication when doing 0-RTT

2016-05-25 Thread Benjamin Kaduk
On 05/24/2016 11:18 PM, Martin Thomson wrote: > On 24 May 2016 at 19:06, Kyle Nekritz wrote: >> What is the rationale for restricting a change in certificate? If the server >> has a new certificate that the client would accept with a full handshake, >> what threat is added by also accepting that

Re: [TLS] Asking for certificate authentication when doing 0-RTT

2016-05-25 Thread Martin Thomson
I think that there are four levels of continuity that make sense here : 1. None. Anthony can change. 2. Server name. I.e. SNI stays constant. 3. Public key (and SNI) stays constant. 4. The certificate stays the same. The use case of short-lived certs is served by 2. 3 might also work. I think tha