On Sat, Jan 6, 2024 at 10:07 AM Orie Steele
wrote:
> Thanks for your detailed response!
>
Even TLS 1.3 is not super clear on this one. I read:
https://datatracker.ietf.org/doc/html/rfc8446#appendix-B.4
And I was a little bit confused. So, you get some all caps with underscores.
These do all w
Thanks for your detailed response!
I agree with everything you wrote, but especially these parts:
> A key is a thing you get out of a signature scheme, not the other way
around.
And this part:
> As far as we're concerned, these are just names that conform to the
signature scheme interface (KeyG
On Sat, Jan 6, 2024 at 12:23 PM David Benjamin
wrote:
> I think this thread stems from a misunderstanding of what TLS is doing,
> and what "Ed25519" means.
>
> > In the thread, Neil said that it is better to negotiate for key
> (representations), instead of algorithms, and that TLS has been movin
I think this thread stems from a misunderstanding of what TLS is doing, and
what "Ed25519" means.
> In the thread, Neil said that it is better to negotiate for key
(representations), instead of algorithms, and that TLS has been moving away
from fully specifying things.
This is the exact opposite
On Sat, Jan 6, 2024 at 9:16 AM Hannes Tschofenig
wrote:
> Hi Orie,
>
>
> I am not sure whether the comparison between JOSE/COSE and TLS is
> appropriate when the latter uses a handshake and the former is a one-shot
> message (or a payload).
>
> In a TLS handshake there are so many things that get
* Hence, I am not sure what the benefit of aligning the registries are. To
me, this entire ciphersuite vs. à la carte discussion is largely a matter of
taste.
Strongly agree. TLS is an online protocol; the others are not.
Perhaps the LAMPS (neé spasm) working has opinions, since JOSE at al
Hi Orie,
I am not sure whether the comparison between JOSE/COSE and TLS is
appropriate when the latter uses a handshake and the former is a
one-shot message (or a payload).
In a TLS handshake there are so many things that get negotiated, such as
the algorithms and parameters for protecting the
Hello,
Apologies in advance for starting a thread about the proper way to name
things.
We've been discussing the TLS naming conventions in relation to JOSE and
COSE naming conventions for suites.
Here is the start of the full thread:
https://mailarchive.ietf.org/arch/msg/jose/66xvb1EgD-bf7V-XyAg
