Re: Moving telnet/telnetd from base to pkgsrc

2018-12-14 Thread Robert Elz
Date:Fri, 14 Dec 2018 21:28:34 -0800 From:John Nemeth Message-ID: <201812150528.wbf5syhr025...@server.cornerstoneservice.ca> | As kre noted, it is probably the oldest network application | around. According to Wikipedia, the protocol was developed in | 1969, pr

Re: Moving telnet/telnetd from base to pkgsrc

2018-12-14 Thread John Nemeth
On Dec 14, 4:22pm, co...@sdf.org wrote: } } You know I'm writing this as telnet on netbsd is vulnerable to remote } exploits, and everyone that can MITM you can do that to you whenever you } 'telnet to see if ports are open'? Name the remote exploit! And, don't tell me about MITM. }-- End

Re: Moving telnet/telnetd from base to pkgsrc

2018-12-14 Thread John Nemeth
On Dec 14, 1:21pm, Taylor R Campbell wrote: } > Date: Fri, 14 Dec 2018 09:46:08 +0100 } > From: Edgar Fuß } > } > > Y'all seem to think it's totally reasonable to telnet in the open internet } > What's the problem with "telnet www.uni-bonn.de http"? } } If the telnet client is remotely exploita

Re: Moving telnet/telnetd from base to pkgsrc

2018-12-14 Thread Michael van Elst
On Fri, Dec 14, 2018 at 04:53:06PM +, Taylor R Campbell wrote: > There is an exploit being privately circulated, which is what prompted > this discussion in the first place, and an advisory is presumably > forthcoming. Two local 'exploits', one that had been fixed more than 13 years ago (with

Re: Moving telnet/telnetd from base to pkgsrc

2018-12-14 Thread Taylor R Campbell
> Date: Fri, 14 Dec 2018 16:34:47 - (UTC) > From: mlel...@serpens.de (Michael van Elst) > > co...@sdf.org writes: > > >You know I'm writing this as telnet on netbsd is vulnerable to remote > >exploits, and everyone that can MITM you can do that to you whenever you > >'telnet to see if ports a

Re: Moving telnet/telnetd from base to pkgsrc

2018-12-14 Thread Michael van Elst
co...@sdf.org writes: >You know I'm writing this as telnet on netbsd is vulnerable to remote >exploits, and everyone that can MITM you can do that to you whenever you >'telnet to see if ports are open'? Obviously wrong. -- -- Michael van Elst Internet: mlel...@s

Re: Moving telnet/telnetd from base to pkgsrc

2018-12-14 Thread Steffen Nurpmeso
Greg Troxel wrote in : |Robert Elz writes: | |> It does no harm as it is, if you don't use the client, all it does is |> occupy a couple of hundred blocks (nothing), the server is not |> enabled by default, and it is even smaller. | |I agree. I use it often, to see if TCP ports are open an

Re: Moving telnet/telnetd from base to pkgsrc

2018-12-14 Thread coypu
You know I'm writing this as telnet on netbsd is vulnerable to remote exploits, and everyone that can MITM you can do that to you whenever you 'telnet to see if ports are open'?

Re: Moving telnet/telnetd from base to pkgsrc

2018-12-14 Thread Christian Groessler
On 12/14/18 2:21 PM, Taylor R Campbell wrote: We should at least have warnings on it until someone takes up maintenance not to use it on the open internet. This comes around to me similar to having a notice in the cup of coffee just bought "Caution: content may be hot", or instructions for

Re: Moving telnet/telnetd from base to pkgsrc

2018-12-14 Thread Michael van Elst
campbell+netbsd-tech-userle...@mumble.net (Taylor R Campbell) writes: >If the telnet client is remotely exploitable Is it? -- -- Michael van Elst Internet: mlel...@serpens.de "A potential Snark may lurk in every tree."

Re: Moving telnet/telnetd from base to pkgsrc

2018-12-14 Thread Taylor R Campbell
> Date: Fri, 14 Dec 2018 09:46:08 +0100 > From: Edgar Fuß > > > Y'all seem to think it's totally reasonable to telnet in the open internet > What's the problem with "telnet www.uni-bonn.de http"? If the telnet client is remotely exploitable then that exposes you to exploitation by www.uni-bonn.d

Re: Moving telnet/telnetd from base to pkgsrc

2018-12-14 Thread Greg Troxel
Robert Elz writes: > It does no harm as it is, if you don't use the client, all it does is > occupy a couple of hundred blocks (nothing), the server is not > enabled by default, and it is even smaller. I agree. I use it often, to see if TCP ports are open and hand-type smtp or http. Another

Re: Moving telnet/telnetd from base to pkgsrc

2018-12-14 Thread Taylor R Campbell
> Date: Fri, 14 Dec 2018 09:41:20 +0100 > From: Edgar Fuß > > > send hate mail my way. > I guess you are over-looking my (and probably a lot of other network > administrator's) primary use case for /usr/bin/telnet: connect to a > HTTP/SMTP/IMAP/whatever port and speak the protocol. That's what

Re: Moving telnet/telnetd from base to pkgsrc

2018-12-14 Thread John Nemeth
On Dec 14, 4:56am, co...@sdf.org wrote: } } The maintenance burden is as follows: } } - Y'all seem to think it's totally reasonable to telnet in the open } internet Nobody thinks it should be used in the open internet in any situation where security is required, at least not without using

Re: Moving telnet/telnetd from base to pkgsrc

2018-12-14 Thread Paul Goyette
On Fri, 14 Dec 2018, Edgar Fu? wrote: send hate mail my way. I guess you are over-looking my (and probably a lot of other network administrator's) primary use case for /usr/bin/telnet: connect to a HTTP/SMTP/IMAP/whatever port and speak the protocol. Yep, there's still a lot of network gear o

Re: /bin/sh startup file processing

2018-12-14 Thread Edgar Fuß
> only current use for the (posix "is undefined") relative path in $ENV is > if the intent is to run the script relative to whatever directory the > shell happens to start in. I doubt that is often intended. I would guess the most probable intent is to run it from $HOME (and wonder why it some

Re: Moving telnet/telnetd from base to pkgsrc

2018-12-14 Thread Edgar Fuß
> Y'all seem to think it's totally reasonable to telnet in the open internet What's the problem with "telnet www.uni-bonn.de http"?

Re: Moving telnet/telnetd from base to pkgsrc

2018-12-14 Thread Edgar Fuß
> send hate mail my way. I guess you are over-looking my (and probably a lot of other network administrator's) primary use case for /usr/bin/telnet: connect to a HTTP/SMTP/IMAP/whatever port and speak the protocol.