Re: [Tagging] source tag on object <> changeset

2017-07-25 Thread ralph.aytoun
Hi marc, I am one that checks both the source and the history of changes to understand why a features was created and from where. JOSM does already have a history and can be accessed by selecting the feature then holding down the Ctrl key and pressing h. The history comes up in a separate wind

Re: [Tagging] source tag on object <> changeset

2017-07-25 Thread Marc Gemis
Hi Ralph, in which cases do you check the history ? If I have a photo (or any other survey material) that show a different reality than what is mapped, why would I then check the source ? It's only when I have no survey material (and I'm armchair mapping from e.g. aerial imagery ) that a source mi

Re: [Tagging] source tag on object <> changeset

2017-07-25 Thread marc marc
Hello Ralph, I also use josm and his history/changeset/diff function, is's nice. But as you said yourself, all info you put at the chansetset level are easy to read... if other mapper want it ! So if comment/source/date is in changeset tag, why duplicate it on every object ? just in case that a

Re: [Tagging] Names containing abbreviations that are the official name

2017-07-25 Thread Martin Koppenhoefer
sent from a phone > On 25. Jul 2017, at 08:41, Colin Smale wrote: > > Unless the word is "St." for Saint in English where there is no evidence that > the full spelling is ever, ever used. rarely, there are some examples though, like Saint Petersburg or Saint Peter's tomb: https://en.m.wik

Re: [Tagging] source tag on object <> changeset

2017-07-25 Thread Martin Koppenhoefer
sent from a phone > On 25. Jul 2017, at 10:17, Marc Gemis wrote: > > in which cases do you check the history ? If I have a photo (or any > other survey material) that show a different reality than what is > mapped, why would I then check the source ? +1, I also see no point in these source t

Re: [Tagging] Names containing abbreviations that are the official name

2017-07-25 Thread Clifford Snow
Saint Paul - but that certainly is an exception. I was using a garmin gps device to navigate about 4 years ago. As I entered Mount Vernon, WA the voice called it Mountain Vernon. Albert Pundt suggestion to use offical_name or name_official would help. But keeping with OSM ground truth, we could u