Re: [Tagging] A leisure tag for bathe

2012-03-12 Thread Erik Johansson
2012/3/11 Johan Jönsson : > I made a try to do go through some examples to see how it worked. They are at: > http://wiki.openstreetmap.org/wiki/User:Johan_J%C3%B6nsson/Workspace > > what I can see, it looks like it is only the open-air public nature bath > locations that really lack tags, swimming_

Re: [Tagging] A leisure tag for bathe

2012-03-12 Thread Colin Smale
There seem to be several dimensions to this. "Bathing" can mean different things to different people, with different English words/usage. I can give a few examples. Firstly, the activity itself: *to get clean (with soap etc) *to exercise or as a sport (swimming pool with lanes) *as

Re: [Tagging] A leisure tag for bathe

2012-03-12 Thread Martin Koppenhoefer
Am 12. März 2012 11:06 schrieb Colin Smale : > combination. I would suggest tagging them separately, to allow full > flexibility and minimise ambiguity. +1 > For the activity, we already have leisure=swimming_pool, for sporting or > recreational swimming in a manmade construction. What you de

Re: [Tagging] A leisure tag for bathe

2012-03-12 Thread Johan Jönsson
Colin Smale writes: > There seem to be several dimensions to this. "Bathing" can mean > different things to different people, with different English > words/usage. I can give a few examples. > > Firstly, the activity itself: > *to get clean (with soap etc) > *to exercise or as a sport (

Re: [Tagging] RFC - Bandstand

2012-03-12 Thread Johan Jönsson
LM_1 writes: > 2012/3/11 Johan Jönsson goteborg.cc>: > > leisure=bandstand is a good tag. > > The bandstand is a prominent feature that is easy to map, so ease of mapping > > with one tag is prefect. > > Is this not bad, having more (independent) information in one tag? Imagine that > person A

Re: [Tagging] RFC - Bandstand

2012-03-12 Thread LM_1
That seems to be almost philosophical question about a perfect tag. I prefer more structured approach, like you proposed for bathing. LM 2012/3/12 Johan Jönsson : > LM_1 writes: >> 2012/3/11 Johan Jönsson goteborg.cc>: >> > leisure=bandstand is a good tag. >> > The bandstand is a prominent featu

Re: [Tagging] RFC - Bandstand

2012-03-12 Thread Bill Ricker
2012/3/11 Johan Jönsson > leisure=bandstand is a good tag. > +1. -- Bill @n1vux bill.n1...@gmail.com ___ Tagging mailing list Tagging@openstreetmap.org http://lists.openstreetmap.org/listinfo/tagging