[Tagging] Why are railway=crossing and level_crossing separate tags?

2012-01-20 Thread Nathan Edgars II
According to the wiki, railway=crossing is "a point where pedestrians may cross a railway", while railway=level_crossing is "where a road crosses a railway". But footways are also represented by highways, and so if one wants to know where pedestrians may cross a railway they can simply look at

Re: [Tagging] Why are railway=crossing and level_crossing separate tags?

2012-01-20 Thread Martijn van Exel
Good question. I just noticed that the other day while using the presets window. I'd say deprecate one of them. I'd be inclined to deprecate level_crossing because crossing is nice and terse. But level_crossing is used more (143k vs 22k for railway=crossing) and railway=crossing causes confusion wi

Re: [Tagging] Why are railway=crossing and level_crossing separate tags?

2012-01-20 Thread Nathan Edgars II
On 1/20/2012 10:49 AM, Nathan Edgars II wrote: According to the wiki, railway=crossing is "a point where pedestrians may cross a railway", while railway=level_crossing is "where a road crosses a railway". But footways are also represented by highways, and so if one wants to know where pedestrians

Re: [Tagging] Why are railway=crossing and level_crossing separate tags?

2012-01-20 Thread LM_1
Actually both highway=crossing and railway=crossing mark a place where you can meet different type of traffic (pedestrian-car, car-train, pedestrian-train...) LM_1 2012/1/20 Martijn van Exel : > Good question. I just noticed that the other day while using the > presets window. I'd say deprecate on

[Tagging] Level and type of school (ISCED, public/private/charter)

2012-01-20 Thread Josh Doe
I've been thinking about how to tag schools, specifically in regards to the level of education offered (primary/secondary, elementary/middle/high) and who operates the school (public/private). For the first, there's some discussion on the school talk page about using the ISCED system: http://wiki.

Re: [Tagging] Level and type of school (ISCED, public/private/charter)

2012-01-20 Thread Richard Mann
Life's too short to argue about something like this. Just use something that's locally meaningful - that's all most mappers will understand, and if there's an international scale, document that and maybe people will use it (but they probably won't). level=secondary/primary works for me If it's s

Re: [Tagging] Level and type of school (ISCED, public/private/charter)

2012-01-20 Thread Pieren
On Fri, Jan 20, 2012 at 8:09 PM, Josh Doe wrote: > Anyone else interested in this? It seems like this would be especially > useful in the developing world. In France, we created the following sub-tag "school:FR" : http://wiki.openstreetmap.org/wiki/Key:school:FR#Valeurs The systems of schooling

Re: [Tagging] Level and type of school (ISCED, public/private/charter)

2012-01-20 Thread Andrew Harvey
I've been using what makes sense locally. For me that is, school:level={primary|secondary|...} school:sector={public|private} school:selective={yes|no} But perhaps I should be using school:au:level, school:au:selective and school:au:sector like Pieren is. Regardless I think it should be up to ma

Re: [Tagging] Level and type of school (ISCED, public/private/charter)

2012-01-20 Thread Josh Doe
On Fri, Jan 20, 2012 at 6:52 PM, Andrew Harvey wrote: > I've been using what makes sense locally. For me that is, > > school:level={primary|secondary|...} > school:sector={public|private} > school:selective={yes|no} > > But perhaps I should be using school:au:level, school:au:selective and > schoo

Re: [Tagging] Level and type of school (ISCED, public/private/charter)

2012-01-20 Thread Eugene Alvin Villar
Don't we already tag tertiary schools differently by the following tags?: amenity=university amenity=college In my country, colleges are a separate classification from universities, so the two tags already somewhat makes sense. But I would like a way to tag if a school provides primary education,

Re: [Tagging] Level and type of school (ISCED, public/private/charter)

2012-01-20 Thread Michael Krämer
Am 21.01.2012 00:53 schrieb "Andrew Harvey" : > In my region you could further mark if the private school is religious > or not and the type of religion, but I haven't actually done any > tagging like that. Recently there has been a discussion on the German list on how to tag religious schools. Mo