Re: [Tagging] landuse for arboretum

2010-11-11 Thread Craig Wallace
On 11/11/2010 02:18, Nathan Edgars II wrote: On Wed, Nov 10, 2010 at 9:01 PM, Richard Welty wrote: perhaps: landuse=botanical_garden collection=arboretum|fruticetum|viticetum|pinetum|... I'd prefer keeping landuse values at a minimum, and using subtags where necessary. For example landuse=re

Re: [Tagging] landuse for arboretum

2010-11-11 Thread M∡rtin Koppenhoefer
2010/11/11 Nathan Edgars II : > On Thu, Nov 11, 2010 at 3:08 AM, Ulf Lamping > wrote: >> beside, that I had to ask leo what conservation means and I'm still not >> sure. Don't be too generic with tags. > > landuse=conservation means that the primary use of the land is to > conserve natural resour

Re: [Tagging] landuse for arboretum

2010-11-11 Thread M∡rtin Koppenhoefer
2010/11/11 Richard Welty : > > landuse=botanical_garden is too specific for landuse IMHO. There is already a proposal for a botanical_garden subtype: http://wiki.openstreetmap.org/wiki/Proposed_features/Garden_specification I agree that leisure is not a good key (similar to tourism). cheers, Ma

Re: [Tagging] landuse for arboretum

2010-11-11 Thread Nathan Edgars II
On Thu, Nov 11, 2010 at 3:08 AM, Ulf Lamping wrote: > beside, that I had to ask leo what conservation means and I'm still not > sure. Don't be too generic with tags. landuse=conservation means that the primary use of the land is to conserve natural resources (in this case trees). Often it's land

Re: [Tagging] landuse for arboretum

2010-11-11 Thread Ulf Lamping
Am 11.11.2010 03:34, schrieb John Smith: On 11 November 2010 12:18, Nathan Edgars II wrote: I'd prefer keeping landuse values at a minimum, and using subtags where necessary. For example landuse=residential something=apartments, not landuse=apartments. Would landuse=conservation work for an arb

Re: [Tagging] landuse for arboretum

2010-11-10 Thread John Smith
On 11 November 2010 12:18, Nathan Edgars II wrote: > I'd prefer keeping landuse values at a minimum, and using subtags > where necessary. For example landuse=residential something=apartments, > not landuse=apartments. Would landuse=conservation work for an > arboretum? +1 landuse=conservation co

Re: [Tagging] landuse for arboretum

2010-11-10 Thread Nathan Edgars II
On Wed, Nov 10, 2010 at 9:01 PM, Richard Welty wrote: > perhaps: > > landuse=botanical_garden > collection=arboretum|fruticetum|viticetum|pinetum|... I'd prefer keeping landuse values at a minimum, and using subtags where necessary. For example landuse=residential something=apartments, not landus

Re: [Tagging] landuse for arboretum

2010-11-10 Thread Richard Welty
On 11/10/10 7:28 PM, John Smith wrote: On 11 November 2010 08:27, Craig Wallace wrote: Wouldn't it be covered by leisure=garden? ie "Place where flowers and other plants are grown in a decorative and structured manner or for scientific purposes." Its just it specifically focuses on trees, as op

Re: [Tagging] landuse for arboretum

2010-11-10 Thread Nathan Edgars II
On Wed, Nov 10, 2010 at 7:28 PM, John Smith wrote: > On 11 November 2010 08:27, Craig Wallace wrote: >> Wouldn't it be covered by leisure=garden? ie "Place where flowers and other >> plants are grown in a decorative and structured manner or for scientific >> purposes." >> Its just it specifically

Re: [Tagging] landuse for arboretum

2010-11-10 Thread John Smith
On 11 November 2010 08:27, Craig Wallace wrote: > Wouldn't it be covered by leisure=garden? ie "Place where flowers and other > plants are grown in a decorative and structured manner or for scientific > purposes." > Its just it specifically focuses on trees, as opposed to flowers or other > plants

Re: [Tagging] landuse for arboretum

2010-11-10 Thread Craig Wallace
On 10/11/2010 22:01, Richard Welty wrote: i'm currently doing the boundaries for the Pine Hollow Arboretum south of Albany NY. none of the current landuse/natural tags seem quite appropriate. landuse=forest and natural= wood are closest, but i'd hesitate to use either without a subtype tag indic

[Tagging] landuse for arboretum

2010-11-10 Thread Richard Welty
i'm currently doing the boundaries for the Pine Hollow Arboretum south of Albany NY. none of the current landuse/natural tags seem quite appropriate. landuse=forest and natural= wood are closest, but i'd hesitate to use either without a subtype tag indicating that it's specifically an arboretum