Re: [Tagging] Residential gardens: deprecate leisure=garden, suggest alternative

2011-05-24 Thread Stephen Hope
On 24 May 2011 20:23, Andrew Chadwick (lists) wrote: > There's a need to address the meanings of overlapping > landuses or possibly even areas generally that I don't really wish to > address in something as simple as a rewording of the docs for gardens. There's not nearly as many overlapping case

Re: [Tagging] Residential gardens: deprecate leisure=garden, suggest alternative

2011-05-24 Thread Andrew Chadwick (lists)
On 24/05/11 10:57, Vincent Pottier wrote: > I'd rather use the residential=garden as it may start a set of values to > describe sub-polygons in a landuse residential. > here http://osm.org/go/0CUOvbQ1-- is a suburb I would improve, there are > grass areas, parkings between buildings. You have lan

Re: [Tagging] Residential gardens: deprecate leisure=garden, suggest alternative

2011-05-24 Thread Vincent Pottier
Le 24/05/2011 10:39, Andrew Chadwick (lists) a écrit : On 24/05/11 00:49, M∡rtin Koppenhoefer wrote: [...] the landuse values describing built-up space should usually not be split below plot size. I'll read that as another vote against small landuse plots, but again: there's nothing in the wiki

Re: [Tagging] Residential gardens: deprecate leisure=garden, suggest alternative

2011-05-24 Thread Andrew Chadwick (lists)
Thanks for the feedback, everyone! I think a plan is emerging, and I've updated http://wiki.openstreetmap.org/wiki/Talk:Tag:leisure%3Dgarden#Deprecate_this_for_private.2C_residential_gardens.3F with the pros and cons of the suggested alternative schemes as I understand them. Right now it looks lik

Re: [Tagging] Residential gardens: deprecate leisure=garden, suggest alternative

2011-05-24 Thread Andrew Chadwick (lists)
On 24/05/11 10:09, Sander Deryckere wrote: > [...] there are lots of > buildings (normal houses, not farms) that stand in the middle of a > farmland [...] > > I do not have a strict opinion whether it should be residential=garden > or garden=residential, but as the first one sounds like a speciali

Re: [Tagging] Residential gardens: deprecate leisure=garden, suggest alternative

2011-05-24 Thread Sander Deryckere
If there would be a consensus on only using landuse=* tags on bigger surfaces (and not for single houses), the use of residential=garden or garden=residential should be possible without it being in a landuse=residential area. In Belgium, the spatial planning is worthless and there are lots of b

Re: [Tagging] Residential gardens: deprecate leisure=garden, suggest alternative

2011-05-24 Thread Andrew Chadwick (lists)
On 24/05/11 00:49, M∡rtin Koppenhoefer wrote: > [...] the landuse values describing built-up space should usually not be > split below plot size. I'll read that as another vote against small landuse plots, but again: there's nothing in the wiki explaining this fact, and in fact landuse is regularl