Re: [sword-devel] need help on a project

2008-01-27 Thread Karl Kleinpaste
"Wade Maxfield" <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> writes: > How can this move forward? It already did, but it seems you didn't notice. Based on the bit of (weak) specification given when you first asked about this a month ago, the next morning I posted a script here which does what you asked. Your question wa

Re: [sword-devel] need help on a project

2008-01-27 Thread jonathon
Wade wrote: > BTW, you can indeed take previous GPL code and convert it to closed, but > you must "fork" it to let that happen. If you are the sole copyright holder of _all_ of the code, you can release an update that has a different license. If anybody else owns the copyright of _any_ of that

Re: [sword-devel] need help on a project

2008-01-27 Thread Wade Maxfield
OK. Very good! I had read one of the comments and either mis-understood it or did understand it and thought that was the purpose of Sword (to not allow anyone to go commercial with it). It seems that what I want to do is in line with what you folks will allow in spirit, and in letter with

Re: [sword-devel] need help on a project

2008-01-27 Thread Chris Little
Wade Maxfield wrote: >Yes, I had intended to sell a gui (and give it away for free (ie: > donationware)). I'm not sure I wanted to do an "end run" on the GPL, > but there are some issues I wished to avoid with the GPL. If it is > truly your desire that no one profit from Sword, you do n

Re: [sword-devel] need help on a project

2008-01-27 Thread Jason Galyon
I appreciate you helping me clue in on this. Even better, I appreciate you helping me understand the concerns, something a license by its nature just can't really convey. I think it is very important to honor your requests (the spirit) and not just get by on technical loopholes (the letter).

Re: [sword-devel] need help on a project

2008-01-27 Thread DM Smith
Wade, I am currently the lead developer for JSword. I think I understand the ramifications of the GPL that you mentioned. I have studied the GPL, line by line, to determine whether I was willing to contribute. The GPL is effective in reaching our goals. AFIK, we are the only open source Bibl

Re: [sword-devel] need help on a project

2008-01-27 Thread jhphx
Wade Maxfield wrote: > >The GPL has provisions in it that allow people to charge an > unspecified "transfer fee" for transferring the software to them. > Once they receive the software, they are free to take it, modify it, > and transfer the unmodified or newly modified code to a new person

Re: [sword-devel] need help on a project

2008-01-27 Thread Wade Maxfield
I apologize! I did not receive the answer to my questions a month ago. I had just signed up, and I think that caused me to miss the answer. I thought it had not made it to the list. Here is a snip from a brief post and my answers: --- >You posted already about a mont

Re: [sword-devel] need help on a project

2008-01-25 Thread peter
You posted already about a month ago and Chris Little did ask you some questions regarding your intentions, but you never cared to answer those. The thought was that you intended to do an ed run around the GPL by creating a GUI which was not GPL-ed. You did not provide any reassurance on this. Wi

Re: [sword-devel] need help on a project

2008-01-25 Thread peter
GPL? Wade Maxfield wrote: >I want to do a sword project that is a little different than what has > been done. (not much different) > >I want a sword server application that can feed scriptures requested to a > client. This would be similar to a web server, but it would serve > scriptures

Re: [sword-devel] need help on a project

2008-01-25 Thread Greg Hellings
The SWORD engine would serve for this purpose wonderfully - but you would need to have someone who was willing to tackle designing a protocol, etc. I'm not sure that there is one at the moment, but it seems that an adaptation of OSIS would be perfect, since it is already well-known and the XML str

[sword-devel] need help on a project

2008-01-25 Thread Wade Maxfield
I want to do a sword project that is a little different than what has been done. (not much different) I want a sword server application that can feed scriptures requested to a client. This would be similar to a web server, but it would serve scriptures. It would have to not crash if a sele