Re: [sword-devel] Wiki Misrepresentation

2009-08-03 Thread Greg Hellings
Peter, I'm going to top post, so forgive that. I know we've been through lots of licensing issues in the past. However, the fact remains that the GPL FAQs as well as the FSF license e-mail answering people have directly responded inquiries from SWORD application developers and stated that it *IS*

Re: [sword-devel] Wiki Misrepresentation

2009-08-03 Thread Ben Morgan
Yes, we have been through this before. The answer we have got from the FSF is that GPL compatible licenses are OK for *all* code of frontends using the library, but of course the whole thing has to operate under the GPLv2 (so you can't get round GPL restrictions by using a compatible license on th

Re: [sword-devel] Wiki Misrepresentation

2009-08-03 Thread Famile von Kaehne
Greg, We have been on teh mailing list through this discussion already a few dozen of times. If you write GUI code for _a_ bible programme and then go looking for a suitable backend, + decide to go for libsword your initial independent GUI code may be under any licence you see fit as long as it

Re: [sword-devel] Wiki Misrepresentation

2009-08-03 Thread jhphx
I think that if you look at other sections of the FAQ you will come to the conclusion that while the new code of the frontend may only need to be GPL-compatible, it could also as a derivative need to be GPL, and either way the combined code must be GPL. So yes, the frontend must be GPL or GPL-c

Re: [sword-devel] Wiki Misrepresentation

2009-08-03 Thread Greg Hellings
On Mon, Aug 3, 2009 at 9:29 AM, DM Smith wrote: > On 08/03/2009 09:58 AM, Greg Hellings wrote: >> >> I was on this page - http://crosswire.org/wiki/Frontends:FeatureList - >> earlier today and noticed the following line: >> All frontends MUST be GPLv2 licensed. (This should be obvious. The >> SWORD

Re: [sword-devel] Wiki Misrepresentation

2009-08-03 Thread DM Smith
On 08/03/2009 09:58 AM, Greg Hellings wrote: I was on this page - http://crosswire.org/wiki/Frontends:FeatureList - earlier today and noticed the following line: All frontends MUST be GPLv2 licensed. (This should be obvious. The SWORD Project is GPLv2-licensed. All derivative works, such as front

[sword-devel] Wiki Misrepresentation

2009-08-03 Thread Greg Hellings
I was on this page - http://crosswire.org/wiki/Frontends:FeatureList - earlier today and noticed the following line: All frontends MUST be GPLv2 licensed. (This should be obvious. The SWORD Project is GPLv2-licensed. All derivative works, such as frontends and utilities, must be GPLv2 or they would