Re: [SR-Users] Nat Detect does not work with GS Phones

2015-07-14 Thread Alberto Sagredo
Thanks Daniel! 2015-07-14 13:11 GMT+02:00 Daniel Tryba : > >If i turn STUN off as Olle mentioned, all worked fine.. but if i have a > >customer that for error it turns ON it does not work in my case.. > > > Any way to force RTP in that cases? > > Just always start the rtpproxy, especially when

Re: [SR-Users] Nat Detect does not work with GS Phones

2015-07-14 Thread Daniel Tryba
>If i turn STUN off as Olle mentioned, all worked fine.. but if i have a >customer that for error it turns ON it does not work in my case.. > Any way to force RTP in that cases? Just always start the rtpproxy, especially when you have a setup where some rtp is handled with non public ips: rout

Re: [SR-Users] Nat Detect does not work with GS Phones

2015-07-14 Thread Alberto Sagredo
Yes you are right , but in my scenario a couple of Asterisk behind NAT must not route RTP directly , all must go to RTP Proxy so i have found that case that for me its not working. Sorry if i haven explained so much.. If i turn STUN off as Olle mentioned, all worked fine.. but if i have a custo

Re: [SR-Users] Nat Detect does not work with GS Phones

2015-07-14 Thread Daniel-Constantin Mierla
Hello, the request has public IP address in Via and Contact, matching the source IP. If you look at the tests you do in the readme of the nathelper module, then the request appears as not being natted, see: - http://kamailio.org/docs/modules/stable/modules/nathelper.html#nathelper.f.nat_uac_test

Re: [SR-Users] Nat Detect does not work with GS Phones

2015-07-14 Thread Daniel Tryba
On Tuesday 14 July 2015 11:56:38 Alberto Sagredo wrote: > I have found an issue detecting NAT of GS 1.4.23 Phones when using Stun on > this phones > > Usual nat_uac_test with numbers 19 and 3 does not seems to detect is behind > nat so NATMANAGE is not called Isn't that the point of using things

Re: [SR-Users] Nat Detect does not work with GS Phones

2015-07-14 Thread Olle E. Johansson
> On 14 Jul 2015, at 11:56, Alberto Sagredo > wrote: > > I have found an issue detecting NAT of GS 1.4.23 Phones when using Stun on > this phones If they activate STUN they signal with a public IP. If they signal with a public IP, they tell us they can handle NAT by themself and require no h