Re: [spring] Clarifications for draft-karboubi-spring-sidlist-optimized-cs-sr-00.txt

2024-05-01 Thread Andrew Stone (Nokia)
Hi Himanshu, Apologies for the delay - been OOO. Thank you for the follow up descriptions below. 1. Thanks for the further explanation in text from the meeting discussion. Similar to Ketan's comment I think there would be benefit having this topic discussed in the document, as without the time

Re: [spring] Clarifications for draft-karboubi-spring-sidlist-optimized-cs-sr-00.txt

2024-05-01 Thread Karboubi, Amal
Hi Christian, The link up/down events are automatically covered by the proposal and do not require manual intervention/coordination. The statement “We assume these changes are done during maintenance-windows and under the supervision of an SDN controller and can be coordinated with the PCE dire

Re: [spring] [**EXTERNAL**] Re: Clarifications for draft-karboubi-spring-sidlist-optimized-cs-sr-00.txt

2024-05-01 Thread Karboubi, Amal
Thanks Ketan, Will update the draft accordingly to clarify the points stated below. Happy to continue discussion and carry this as independent work until then. Cheers, Amal. From: Ketan Talaulikar Sent: Saturday, April 27, 2024 2:31 AM To: Shah, Himanshu Cc: Karboubi, Amal ; spring@ietf.org;

Re: [spring] Clarifications for draft-karboubi-spring-sidlist-optimized-cs-sr-00.txt

2024-05-01 Thread Karboubi, Amal
Thanks Andrew, Will make sure the explanation provided below are clearly captured in draft and we can continue discussion, as necessary. Cheers, Amal. From: Andrew Stone (Nokia) Sent: Wednesday, May 1, 2024 11:30 AM To: Ketan Talaulikar ; Shah, Himanshu Cc: Karboubi, Amal ; spring@ietf.org; z

Re: [spring] Clarifications for draft-karboubi-spring-sidlist-optimized-cs-sr-00.txt

2024-05-01 Thread Shah, Himanshu
Thanks Andrew, Ketan and Christian for your valuable input. As Amal indicated, we will revise the draft with more clarifications and progress it in WG as a separate work item. At some later point, we can rediscuss if this work should be rolled in to the CS-SR draft or distinct enough to pursue as i