Re: [S3tools-general] empty directories not syncing - known issue

2014-03-12 Thread WagnerOne
Thank you, Matt. I appreciate this explanation from the s3cmd point of view. This improves my growing understanding of S3 and how to best work with it. Mike On Mar 11, 2014, at 8:44 PM, Matt Domsch wrote: > TL;DR: yes, it's known. No, it's not expected to get fixed soon, if ever. > --delete

Re: [S3tools-general] empty directories not syncing - known issue

2014-03-12 Thread WagnerOne
Thanks for your thoughts. That is my impression about empty directories or the existence of directories at all in S3 too. I was trying to replicate a hierarchy exactly out of habit. I don't think it's ultimately a requirement for my needs. Mike On Mar 12, 2014, at 2:26 PM, j.merr...@enlyton.co

Re: [S3tools-general] empty directories not syncing - known issue

2014-03-12 Thread j . merrill
My impression is that there is no such thing as an "empty directory" on S3. There really aren't hierarchical folders/directories -- it is a flat namespace. Using / as a delimiter gives the illusion of a hierarchy, because you can have bucket.s3.com/one/two/file.x bucket.s3.com/one/two/file.y bu

Re: [S3tools-general] empty directories not syncing - known issue

2014-03-11 Thread Matt Domsch
TL;DR: yes, it's known. No, it's not expected to get fixed soon, if ever. --delete-removed will ignore it on download too, and not delete any such local empty directory. S3 fundamentally is an object store, not a file system. At least that's how it was originally presented to be, and what s3cmd