Re: silent data corruption with rsync

2014-03-13 Thread Pavel Herrmann
se. However, if direct replication of storage is what you are after, I would suggest using filesystem snapshots and snapshot-level replication functionality of your filesystem/volume manager/SAN instead of rsync regards Pavel Herrmann > > regards > Roland > > >List:

Re: silent data corruption with rsync

2014-03-13 Thread Henri Shustak
> Anyway, if "They" care about their data , "They" use checksumming for storing > their data on disk, do "They" ? ;) silent bitrot on disks _does_ happen I totally agree. Storage devices fail and if you need to know if the data is the same then a checksum is your best bet. If you want to do you

Re: silent data corruption with rsync

2014-03-13 Thread devzero
ere some SAN storage lost some cache contents and the only place we really knew where data loss/curruption has happend were the oracle and exchange databases. For all the other data, we don`t know if they are in 100% perfect condition. regards Roland >List: rsync >Subject:silen

Re: silent data corruption with rsync

2014-03-11 Thread Leen Besselink
On Tue, Mar 11, 2014 at 11:52:51AM -0500, Karl O. Pinc wrote: > On 03/11/2014 11:02:28 AM, Sig Pam wrote: > > Hi everbody! > > > > I'm currently working in a project which has to copy huge amounts of > > data from one storage to another. For a reason I cannot validate any > > longer, there is a ro

Re: silent data corruption with rsync

2014-03-11 Thread Kevin Korb
-BEGIN PGP SIGNED MESSAGE- Hash: SHA1 I have actually witnessed rsync silently corrupting data. But it wasn't rsync's fault. I had a bad RAM DIMM that was corrupting the part of RAM being used as the disk cache. Now I always get ECC RAM. On 03/11/2014 12:52 PM, Karl O. Pinc wrote: > On

Re: silent data corruption with rsync

2014-03-11 Thread Karl O. Pinc
On 03/11/2014 11:02:28 AM, Sig Pam wrote: > Hi everbody! > > I'm currently working in a project which has to copy huge amounts of > data from one storage to another. For a reason I cannot validate any > longer, there is a roumor that "rsync may silently corrupt data". > Personally, I don't believe

silent data corruption with rsync

2014-03-11 Thread Sig Pam
Hi everbody! I'm currently working in a project which has to copy huge amounts of data from one storage to another. For a reason I cannot validate any longer, there is a roumor that "rsync may silently corrupt data". Personally, I don't believe that. "They" explain it this way: "rsync does an i