Re: Rsync: Re: password prompts

2001-04-11 Thread Dave Dykstra
On Sat, Apr 07, 2001 at 02:53:13AM +0100, M. Drew Streib wrote: > The net-net is: > > On the box accepting the connection w/o a password from another box with > the private key, the security of the accepting box is _only_ as good as > the account on the originating box. Strike that "w/o a passwo

Re: Rsync: Re: password prompts

2001-04-10 Thread Ian Goldberg
In article <005691001131455102L112*@MHS>, <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> wrote: >chroot does nothing to hide uid 0. It makes a subdirectory appear as /, >so you can give somebody access to /publicdirectory, and to them it's >/... they can't cd out of that heirarchy to the rest of your filesystem. >No h

Re: Rsync: Re: password prompts

2001-04-09 Thread tim . conway
[EMAIL PROTECTED]@[EMAIL PROTECTED] on 04/07/2001 06:57:14 AM Sent by:[EMAIL PROTECTED] To: [EMAIL PROTECTED]@SMTP cc: [EMAIL PROTECTED]@SMTP Subject: Re: Rsync: Re: password prompts Classification: Lachlan, Thanks for the response! I haven't tried it yet, but does

Re: Rsync: Re: password prompts

2001-04-09 Thread tim . conway
; I'm sure somebody like Martin could use this, run as nobody, to get a root shell, but it would sure keep me out. Tim Conway [EMAIL PROTECTED] 303.682.4917 Philips Semiconductor - Colorado TC 1880 Industrial Circle Suite D Longmont, CO 80501 [EMAIL PROTECTED]@[EMAIL PROTECTED] on 04

Re: Rsync: Re: password prompts (fwd)

2001-04-08 Thread M. Drew Streib
On Sat, Apr 07, 2001 at 08:00:19PM +0100, L. Cranswick wrote: > FTP and Rsync via SSH to update files - how many users do this? > I don't think I have persuaded one person to do this - they all > think it too inconvenient - too much new stuff to learn - and it > takes discipline to stick with it.

Re: Rsync: Re: password prompts

2001-04-08 Thread Randy Kramer
Rob, Thanks for the explanation! Randy Kramer Rob Russell wrote: > chroot is the act of changing the root directory of a filesystem as it > appears to the process. (man 1 chroot) > > So, if I make an [x]inetd entry that calls "chroot /var/ssh sshd" instead > of sshd, then when inetd passes th

Re: Rsync: Re: password prompts

2001-04-07 Thread Rob Russell
On Sat, 7 Apr 2001, Randy Kramer wrote: > I don't think our descriptions are very different, but why, once you > create the account with restricted file permission is it called > "chrooted" -- does the user of the account think it's a root account, or > is it just that it's his "root" account, as

Re: Rsync: Re: password prompts (fwd)

2001-04-07 Thread Rob Russell
On Sat, 7 Apr 2001, L. Cranswick wrote: > > So I recompiled OpenSSH to use a different port, and have a different name > > (BrokenSSH, or "bs" for short). I installed it on the receiving box in a > > chrooted environment, configured its sshd_config and ran it thorugh tcp > > wrappers so that onl

Re: Rsync: Re: password prompts

2001-04-07 Thread Randy Kramer
Lachlan, Thanks for the further response! L. Cranswick wrote: > (Sorry for previous Emails dated 1991 - No problem! > On a general discussion on using a passphrase/password based approach: > A silly question from me. Why would you need both a public file > and a passphrase? As I understan

Re: Rsync: Re: password prompts (fwd)

2001-04-07 Thread L. Cranswick
> > > Indeed, the biggest reason to use an external ssh program is that it > > makes security updates *someone else's* problem -- ideally someone who > > cares and/or is good at it. ("Put all your eggs in one basket and > > *watch that basket*" :-) Seriously, when an ssh bug comes up (and more >

Re: Rsync: Re: password prompts

2001-04-07 Thread L. Cranswick
> Thanks for the response! I haven't tried it yet, but does ssh with a > passphrase address your concern? If somebody steals your private key > can it be used without the passphrase? (Sorry for previous Emails dated 1991 - have to do this to run an old freeware DOS scientific analysis program

Re: Rsync: Re: password prompts

2001-04-07 Thread Rob Russell
On 7 Apr 2001, Mark W. Eichin wrote: > Indeed, the biggest reason to use an external ssh program is that it > makes security updates *someone else's* problem -- ideally someone who > cares and/or is good at it. ("Put all your eggs in one basket and > *watch that basket*" :-) Seriously, when an s

Re: Rsync: Re: password prompts

2001-04-07 Thread Mark W. Eichin
> >As for implementing ssh inside of rsync, I'd like to continue to reiterate > >what a bad idea I think that is. Security is enough pain without worrying Indeed, the biggest reason to use an external ssh program is that it makes security updates *someone else's* problem -- ideally someone who ca

Re: Rsync: Re: password prompts

2001-04-07 Thread Randy Kramer
Lachlan, Thanks for the response! I haven't tried it yet, but does ssh with a passphrase address your concern? If somebody steals your private key can it be used without the passphrase? Thanks, Randy Kramer PS: Thanks for the discussion. From what you've said and other things I've heard befo

Re: Rsync: Re: password prompts

2001-04-06 Thread Lachlan Cranswick
>Not fully understanding the ramifications of chroot (as a Linux newbie) >I don't really know whether limiting someone's access by chrooting is >any more effective than limiting his access based on privileges provided >to his account. Re: rsync, ssh, security and keeping hackers out. (just my

Re: Rsync: Re: password prompts

2001-04-06 Thread Randy Kramer
Hello Lachlan, Lachlan Cranswick wrote: > (Before waffling on a side tracked issue - there is still a > request for good web based passwordless ssh tutorials) I don't really have anything to offer -- I learned some about public / private key systems over a lot of years starting with a signature

Re: Rsync: Re: password prompts

2001-04-06 Thread Lachlan Cranswick
>As for implementing ssh inside of rsync, I'd like to continue to reiterate >what a bad idea I think that is. Security is enough pain without worrying >about every program carrying its own security model and implementation (and >possible exploits). What if such a feature was an optional module t

Re: Rsync: Re: password prompts

2001-04-06 Thread Lachlan Cranswick
Hi Randy (and rsync list), (Before waffling on a side tracked issue - there is still a request for good web based passwordless ssh tutorials) I must apologise as usual for poor elaboration of my paranoia against passwordless ssh. I roughly agree with your assessment. However, the thing that

Re: Rsync: Re: password prompts

2001-04-06 Thread M. Drew Streib
On Fri, Apr 06, 2001 at 09:33:04PM -0400, Randy Kramer wrote: > Now, I may be wrong in my understanding, but, for a moment, please > assume I'm right. If I am right, and the security provided by a > passwordless ssh connection is just as good as, for example, PGP (assume > I'm right about that to

Re: Rsync: Re: password prompts

2001-04-06 Thread Randy Kramer
Lachlan, Excuse me for jumping into this discussion, especially being something of a newbie. As I understand ssh without passwords, it is very secure because it is based on a public / private key scheme, something like PGP. When you set up a passwordless ssh system, you create a public and priv

Rsync: Re: password prompts

2001-04-06 Thread Lachlan Cranswick
Might there be a good set of tutorials on the web on how to do this while minimizing the risk of exposing systems as a consequence? (setup of private/public identity files that minimize the risk of hackers getting passwordless access to other remote machines). I must admit hating the passwordl