RE: About zero counts etc.

2006-10-13 Thread AlanCoelho
Title: RE: About zero counts etc. Hi Bill   Excellent, thank you, I am surprised that I understand what you are saying for a change.   In other words instead of squaring some function F^2 to minimize on you instead simply minimize on a more general function G. Its the squaring that leads to

RE: About zero counts etc.

2006-10-13 Thread David, WIF \(Bill\)
Title: RE: About zero counts etc. Hi Alan, The short answer is that the question of zero counts can indeed be answered in a simple and practical manner. There's a lot of apparent mystique about probability theory especially when one invokes the term Bayesian probability theory. Ho

RE: About zero counts etc.

2006-10-13 Thread AlanCoelho
Alan From: David, WIF (Bill) [mailto:[EMAIL PROTECTED] Sent: Thursday, 12 October 2006 4:48 PM To: rietveld_l@ill.fr Subject: RE: About zero counts etc. Dear all, Jon's right - when the counts are very low - i.e. zeroes and ones around - then the correct Bayesian appr

RE: About zero counts etc.

2006-10-11 Thread David, WIF \(Bill\)
Title: RE: About zero counts etc. Dear all, Jon's right - when the counts are very low - i.e. zeroes and ones around - then the correct Bayesian approach is to use Poisson statistics. This, as Jon said, has been tackled by Antoniadis et al. (Acta Cryst. (1990). A46, 692-711  Ma

Re: About zero counts etc.

2006-10-11 Thread wright
Hello Joerg, > -Having measured n counts, the estimated value is n+1 You might have a hard time convincing me on that one. > -Having measured n counts, the esd is also sqrt(n+1)! If n is zero then spending more time on the data collection might be better than more time on the analysis. > Thing

About zero counts etc.

2006-10-11 Thread Joerg Bergmann
Hi all, from time to time, the problem of zero values in the pattern is discussed. I have done an indepth Bayesian approach: Have assumed identical probability of all values prior to measurement and have calculated the Bayesian distribution of probabilities after having measured n counts, its est