Re: RES: ADS

2008-05-29 Thread Lubomir Smrcok
Hi, I really wonder why do you bother about 1% difference when the error of the method (XRD, quantitative phase analysis) could reach 10% (absolute) ... People in the discussions appearing here seem to forget about two things: i) "quantitative" phase analysis done by rietveld method is always

Re: ADS

2008-05-29 Thread Reinhard Kleeberg
Periclase is really problematic because of the small number of peaks in the usual angular range used for QPA with Cu or Co radiation. Thus, the particle statistics problem becomes extremely critic, as Pamela already said. The uncertainties can be compared with the statistical intensity errors o

Problem with MAUD

2008-05-29 Thread soumen ghosh
Which background function is suitable for Rietveld refinement using the program MAUD? Is it polynomial or the interpolated function? And which parameters determine the zero shift? With regards Soumen Ghosh Department of Physics Jadavpur University Kolkata-700032, India --

Problem with MAUD

2008-05-29 Thread soumen ghosh
Which background function is suitable for Rietveld refinement using the program MAUD? Is it polynomial or the interpolated function? And which parameters determine the zero shift? With regards Soumen Ghosh Department of Physics Jadavpur University Kolkata-700032, India

RE: ADS

2008-05-29 Thread Whitfield, Pamela
I'm afraid that 30 microns might be small to the eye but is too big for quant analysis. The particles need to be in the range of a micron or two. There's an old paper by Deane Smith that did a brilliant job of showing the effects in a statistical manner. Pam From: José Carlos Cordeiro

RES: ADS

2008-05-29 Thread José Carlos Cordeiro
My samples are cements (fine samples with 30 microns) and don't need micronize its. The problem in my refinements is that periclase quantified with fixed slit is bigger than MgO by Fluorescence, and its impossible. Ex: Periclase with fixed slit: 7,14% MgO by XRF = 6,84% We know that part

RE: ADS

2008-05-29 Thread Whitfield, Pamela
Hi Jose Errors in the region of 1wt% aren't unheard of in complex mixtures (and the liklihood of the second decimal place being meaningful is very slim). However there are other possible explanations and one in particular comes to mind. Did you micronize your sample? If yes then feel free to

ADS

2008-05-29 Thread José Carlos Cordeiro
I have a Programmable Divergence Slit (incident beam) in my difratctometer, that can work in automatic mode (irradiated length) or fixed mode (0.5 degree or 1.0 degree etc). What is the best collect mode for Rietveld Refinament?? I did refinement two difractograms collected in booth configura