[regext] Re: Fwd: using experimental to move items forward

2024-06-20 Thread Mario Loffredo
Hi Andy, [snip] On 6/18/24 04:29, Mario Loffredo wrote: Hi Andy, what does it mean "interoperable implementation" in RegExt context ? Best, Mario It means the protocol/extension works as expected. If Bob were to create a client with extension Foo and Alice were to create a server wit

[regext] Re: Fwd: using experimental to move items forward

2024-06-20 Thread Andrew Newton (andy)
On 6/20/24 03:35, Mario Loffredo wrote: Hi Andy, [snip] On 6/18/24 04:29, Mario Loffredo wrote: Hi Andy, what does it mean "interoperable implementation" in RegExt context ? Best, Mario It means the protocol/extension works as expected. If Bob were to create a client with extension

[regext] Re: Does section 3.7 of RFC 8748 forbid standard fees for non-standard (aka premium) domains?

2024-06-20 Thread Thomas Corte (TANGO support)
Hello Ryan, On 20.06.24 00:59, Ryan Jaeb wrote: Hi, The end of section 3.7 says: " Servers that make use of this element MUST use a element with the value "standard" for all objects that are subject to the standard or default fee. " Does that forbid a response to a "check' command where fee

[regext] Re: Does section 3.7 of RFC 8748 forbid standard fees for non-standard (aka premium) domains?

2024-06-20 Thread Gould, James
Thomas, I agree that the class is at the domain-level attribute and not at the command-level attribute, that why it's placed as a sibling element of the objID element. The "standard" attribute was added at the command-level to support a mix of standard and non-standard fees for a non-standard

[regext] Re: Fwd: New Version Notification for draft-newton-regext-rdap-considerations-on-rfc9537-00.txt

2024-06-20 Thread rcar...@godaddy.com
Good Afternoon, I was not sure if I should reply to this thread or the "Simple" thread but as the "Simple" thread appears to be a product of this one, I thought I would post here. Several years ago, there were many discussions (in the REGEXT WG, the RDAP WG and others) on how to handle redacti