Hi Jack,
Skimming through the document I have 3 questions / observations:
1) why you decided to break the flow into 2 commands with create and
validate? What shall happen afterwards to the object(s) created in the
first step? In this context the approach in draft-ietf-regext-validate
to have
Hi Andy,
please find my comments inline.
Il 15/11/2023 14:41, Andrew Newton ha scritto:
Mario (and JG),
On Wed, Nov 15, 2023 at 5:17 AM Mario Loffredo
wrote:
[ML] About preserving query parameters in HTTP redirection, my opinion
is that it depends on each application protocol built over HTT
Hi Pawel,
Great questions, see inline.
I’ve seen a few other emails on different ID that had simar concept, we can
integrate for sure. Didn’t get a change to read/skim those.
Jacques
CLASSIFICATION:CONFIDENTIAL
From: kowa...@denic.de
Sent: November 16, 2023 3:27 AM
To: Jacques Latour ; r
Jim,
You are now stating that redirection is a "special case" and using the
word "claim" which I perceive as you being dismissive of the validity
of their need. As I have repeatedly written on this list and these
threads, redirection is very much used when dealing with the transfer
of number resou
Andy,
I didn't mean to be dismissive of the existence or need of redirection
services. I just don't view the redirection services as the primary use case
for RDAP servers and the RDAP protocol itself. We can agree to disagree on
this.
The reason for the word "claim" is to address a gap tha
Mario,
On Thu, Nov 16, 2023 at 9:28 AM Mario Loffredo
wrote:
>
>
> Also, since you (and JG) have been arguing vehemently on your
> position, did you find a technical flaw in the rdap-x draft? Have you
> found a scenario where it does not work?
>
> [ML] Am not "arguing vehemently", I'm quietly exp
Jim,
I offered two very concrete examples of the problem and you have once
again called it a "claim". And you don't see how that can be perceived
as dismissive?
Anway, Jasdip already answered your broader question, and now you are
asking for discussion on hypotheticals that are likely to meander.
Andy,
Jasdip just answered "no" to the question around addressing the broader
question and did not provide any details. You did not answer my question
around TLD transitions, and you have not answered the question related to when
query parameters can and cannot be used in RDAP.
Thanks,
--
Hi Jacques,
A couple of observations:
1. Would it be possible to allow the registry to determine if the
verification can be done instantly or needs to be delayed. If it is instantly,
return a 1000 with the results, if it can't return 1001. If the verification
can be done instantly a veri
