[RBW] Re: Non Brooks Saddle recommendations please.

2010-11-23 Thread RonaTD
My problem with WTB saddles is the back is too flat (side to side), giving that sensation of it being too wide between the legs. The saddle I've recently discovered, thanks to Sean at Rawland, is the Afton Classic from Dimension. You can have your local LBS order one from QBP, or find a place on t

[RBW] Re: Non Brooks Saddle recommendations please.

2010-11-23 Thread bfd
Yeah, I know what you guys mean! I love Avocet O2 saddles and have about 1/2 dozen in various conditions. I plan to try a saddle recover service like this one when mine start wearing out: http://sfbay.craigslist.org/eby/bik/2066484291.html $30 isn't too bad a price to recover a saddle. The guy de

[RBW] Re: Non Brooks Saddle recommendations please.

2010-11-23 Thread Peter Pesce
Advice will only go so far. There's just nothing, not shoes, not underwear, nothing, that's as personal and unique as saddle fit. One man's easy chair is another man's fence post! If you can find a shop that has the WTB Test Ride program that Jim Thill mentioned above, give that a try. Also, some L

[RBW] Re: Non Brooks Saddle recommendations please.

2010-11-23 Thread Montclair BobbyB
Admittedly I have a bit of a Brooks "dependency", but despite having a strong opinion on this topic, I speak the truth. Since I've been riding Brooks B17s on my road and mountain bikes, all my comfort problems have vanished. I no longer even ride with padded shorts (thank God)... In fact, my new

Re: [RBW] Re: Non Brooks Saddle recommendations please.

2010-11-23 Thread James Warren
This one is making its way onto all my bikes. By far my favorite. Check out the built-in saddlebag loops: http://www.specialized.com/us/en/bc/SBCEqProduct.jsp?spid=57843 (If Bridgestone and Rivendell hadn't caught my attention decades ago, I'd probably be a spaz for Specialized.) On Nov 22,

[RBW] Re: Non Brooks Saddle recommendations please.

2010-11-22 Thread William
I have two of the so called men's Ti O2 as my go fast saddle inventory. I know what you mean about reluctance to share your secrets. On Nov 22, 8:54 pm, Mojo wrote: > I have found the long-discontinued Avocet O2 women's saddle works > great for my offroad bike. It has a flat back and a mid-profi

[RBW] Re: Non Brooks Saddle recommendations please.

2010-11-22 Thread Mojo
I have found the long-discontinued Avocet O2 women's saddle works great for my offroad bike. It has a flat back and a mid-profile dip like the B17. It is a bit wider and shorter than the B17 but works well for my butt. For reference, I am 6ft, 195lbs, 34 inch waisted pants. I hesitated to mention

[RBW] Re: Non Brooks Saddle recommendations please.

2010-11-22 Thread Bill M.
I've tried a couple of WTB saddles (Vigo and Pure V), and while they're OK, neither completely got rid of my soft tissue discomfort. Two that do work for me are a Specialized Alias on my go-fast, and the wider Terry Liberator Y "Gelissimo". For a B17 replacement, I'd recommend the Terry. its gel

[RBW] Re: Non Brooks Saddle recommendations please.

2010-11-22 Thread EricP
WTB Laser V works for me. Been riding using that on the Fargo off and on for the past couple of months. Otherwise, I'll be the lone voice and advocate Terry saddles. Have a couple of them and rotate them in and out. Have to admit to a love/hate relationship this year with Brooks saddles. Love

[RBW] Re: Non Brooks Saddle recommendations please.

2010-11-22 Thread Minh
Another vote from me for WTB, it's the closest i've found to the Brooks for me. -- You received this message because you are subscribed to the Google Groups "RBW Owners Bunch" group. To post to this group, send email to rbw-owners-bu...@googlegroups.com. To unsubscribe from this group, send emai

[RBW] Re: Non Brooks Saddle recommendations please.

2010-11-22 Thread james
I can't believe nobody has suggested just cutting out a hole in the brooks saddle. Isn't that what Grant would say and did say in one of those recent readers? a knife, courage and a hole my friend! james -- You received this message because you are subscribed to the Google Groups "RBW Owners

[RBW] Re: Non Brooks Saddle recommendations please.

2010-11-22 Thread Travis
The most comfortable non-Brooks (style saddle) I own is a Specialized Romin. It's one of the few cut-out saddles I've tried which actually seem to succeed in relieving pressure. Also, the Romin comes in various widths, and if you go to a Specialized dealer you can ask to be measured on the ass-o-me

[RBW] Re: Non Brooks Saddle recommendations please.

2010-11-22 Thread Jeremy Till
Another suggestion for WTB saddles. I just put a Speed V (their cheapest saddle) from a town bike i sold on my road bike and discovered that it's quite comfortable for long rides. No pressure on the nether regions. I've never ridden a Brooks for anything more than a hundred yards or so I can't c

[RBW] Re: Non Brooks Saddle recommendations please.

2010-11-22 Thread Michael_S
My preference is the WTB Pure V saddle as an alternate to Brooks. The all leather Team version is very comfortable to sit in and has a middle channel to minimize pressure under there. Another is the Selle Italia Flite Max, both are farily wide, but not as wide as the B17 . ~Mike~ On Nov 22, 8:

[RBW] Re: Non Brooks Saddle recommendations please.

2010-11-22 Thread LBleriot
What about a B17 Imperial. You get to stay with the Brooks and you get the slot. I find the Imperial comfortable right out of the box. On Nov 22, 10:02 am, JGS wrote: > Hey there, > > I've been riding w/ Brooks saddle for several years and I've come to > worry that I'm putting too much pressure

[RBW] Re: Non Brooks Saddle recommendations please.

2010-11-22 Thread Bill Lucas
I have just spent a bit of time on WTB Pure V. It was very comfortable and cheap. The problem with it is that "waist” is wide. The saddle always felt big between my legs. I looked at other WTB saddles and the wide mid section seems to be part of the design. Still, it is worth a try. If a Brooks

[RBW] Re: Non Brooks Saddle recommendations please.

2010-11-22 Thread Jim Thill - Hiawatha Cyclery
Some shops may have the WTB Test Ride Program, which is basically a collection of specially-marked and loaner saddles that you can try before you buy. We have sold a lot of WTB saddles this way. The two most popular are the Rocket (narrow-ish) and the Pure (wider, similar dimensions to a B17). All

[RBW] Re: Non Brooks Saddle recommendations please.

2010-11-22 Thread Forrest
I've had good luck with some Specialized Body Geometry saddles -- Avatar Gel for sport (comes in different widths), and the Milano (also comes in a gel version) for commuting/upright riding. -- Forrest (Iowa City) On Nov 22, 9:41 am, Peter Pesce wrote: > Not sure I'd want to leave a Brooks outs

[RBW] Re: Non Brooks Saddle recommendations please.

2010-11-22 Thread Peter Pesce
Not sure I'd want to leave a Brooks outside in NYC either! I've heard good things about WTB saddles - and they make a pretty wide variety, so finding a good fit should be possible. Many of them come in a simple black design, which would look ok. Some other designs are too flashy for my tastes. I

Re: [RBW] Re: Non Brooks Saddle recommendations please.

2010-11-22 Thread cyclotourist
Really like the WTB Devo/Deva. Only difference is screen printing AFAIK. Plus the added benefit of titanium rails, so you'll be faster, better rested, and undoubtedly smell better. http://www.wtb.com/products/saddles/racing/devo/ On Mon, Nov 22, 2010 at 7:17 AM, JGS wrote: > I do ride w/ the

[RBW] Re: Non Brooks Saddle recommendations please.

2010-11-22 Thread JGS
I do ride w/ the nose tipped up, which helps but not enough. I think part of the problem is that I'm in many different positions since I mostly ride as a commuter. When I ride more for sport and can shift my weight forward the pressure tends to move to my sit bones where it should be. I've alway