[RBW] Re: Lightweight wheels question: J bend vs straight pull (Ritchey vs Hunt)

2023-01-18 Thread ascpgh
What I've always wondered about straight pull vs. J-bend spokes is the risk/benefit comparison. The fixtures necessary to create on the straight pull hub that receive force concentrated by the head of the spoke need to be more robust than a conventional drilled hub flange. They have greater co

Re: [RBW] Re: Lightweight wheels question: J bend vs straight pull (Ritchey vs Hunt)

2023-01-17 Thread 藍俊彪
Spoke tension wasn't an issue until hubs with wR went down to ridiculous level. On one of my recent builds I discovered that the non-drive side was definitely too loose if I tensioned the drive side to Velocity's specs. So I made the decision to just tension the spokes to beyond velocity's specs fo

Re: [RBW] Re: Lightweight wheels question: J bend vs straight pull (Ritchey vs Hunt)

2023-01-17 Thread Will Boericke
Totally agree with John's wheels. If I didn't like building wheels so much, I'd buy his for sure. As far as spoke tension imbalance, I'll reserve judgement until I have a problem. Currently, I have 8 bikes with 9+ speed freehubs. I've never had a spoke tension related problem with any, inclu

Re: [RBW] Re: Lightweight wheels question: J bend vs straight pull (Ritchey vs Hunt)

2023-01-17 Thread Andrew Turner
John at Neugent Cycles strikes me as "the real deal" with the right connections and knowledge of modern wheel-building practices. Plus I could be wrong but I think he's building these wheels himself, regardless they're hand-built here stateside. (He let me mail some SimWorks' raw brass nipples

Re: [RBW] Re: Lightweight wheels question: J bend vs straight pull (Ritchey vs Hunt)

2023-01-17 Thread 藍俊彪
Andrew is correct. I made a mistake --- the washers are on the drive side, not the non-drive side. On Tue, Jan 17, 2023 at 10:20 AM Andrew Turner wrote: > Washers are put on the drive-side rear spokes. > > Andrew > > On Tuesday, January 17, 2023 at 12:16:43 PM UTC-6 lconley wrote: > >> So if the

Re: [RBW] Re: Lightweight wheels question: J bend vs straight pull (Ritchey vs Hunt)

2023-01-17 Thread Andrew Turner
Washers are put on the drive-side rear spokes. Andrew On Tuesday, January 17, 2023 at 12:16:43 PM UTC-6 lconley wrote: > So if the drive side spokes have higher tension, why are the washers put > on the non-drive side spokes? Again, makes no sense to me. > > Laing > > > On Tuesday, January 17,

Re: [RBW] Re: Lightweight wheels question: J bend vs straight pull (Ritchey vs Hunt)

2023-01-17 Thread lconley
So if the drive side spokes have higher tension, why are the washers put on the non-drive side spokes? Again, makes no sense to me. Laing On Tuesday, January 17, 2023 at 10:20:40 AM UTC-5 pi...@gmail.com wrote: The drive side still has higher tension, and the way to get durable wheels is to get

Re: [RBW] Re: Lightweight wheels question: J bend vs straight pull (Ritchey vs Hunt)

2023-01-17 Thread 藍俊彪
If you feel that your wheels are already plenty strong and durable enough, sure. But what I've discovered over the years is that hubs have gotten their wR smaller and smaller, which reduces the bracing angle and increases the difference in tension between drive and non-drive side wheels. https://b

Re: [RBW] Re: Lightweight wheels question: J bend vs straight pull (Ritchey vs Hunt)

2023-01-17 Thread Bill Lindsay
I wonder when we'll see a new Gus Boots Willsen build with a 16/8 rear wheel? Bill Lindsay El Cerrito, CA On Tuesday, January 17, 2023 at 7:59:15 AM UTC-8 wboe...@gmail.com wrote: > Not a huge fan of the 16/8 idea for this reason. Seems like a solution in > search of a problem. > > > > On T

Re: [RBW] Re: Lightweight wheels question: J bend vs straight pull (Ritchey vs Hunt)

2023-01-17 Thread Will Boericke
Not a huge fan of the 16/8 idea for this reason. Seems like a solution in search of a problem. On Tue, Jan 17, 2023 at 10:20 AM Piaw Na(藍俊彪) wrote: > The drive side still has higher tension, and the way to get durable wheels > is to get high tension without cracking the rim. The washers sprea

Re: [RBW] Re: Lightweight wheels question: J bend vs straight pull (Ritchey vs Hunt)

2023-01-17 Thread 藍俊彪
The drive side still has higher tension, and the way to get durable wheels is to get high tension without cracking the rim. The washers spread the load of the spoke nipple over a wider area and prevents the rim from cracking. With lowish spoke count wheels and dished wheels, you can easily exceed t

[RBW] Re: Lightweight wheels question: J bend vs straight pull (Ritchey vs Hunt)

2023-01-17 Thread lconley
So if the spoke tension is equal on both sides, why would one side need washers? Makes no sense to me. Laing On Monday, January 16, 2023 at 4:44:22 PM UTC-5 pi...@gmail.com wrote: > I would consider Ted Neugent's wheels: > http://www.neugentcycling.com/Alloy-Wheels.html > > The TwoX technology

[RBW] Re: Lightweight wheels question: J bend vs straight pull (Ritchey vs Hunt)

2023-01-16 Thread Will Boericke
DT Swiss 240 to a 450g rim (Archetype, DT 450, Kinlin TL-21, etc) all day long. I own 2 sets of these - bombproof and light. All parts can be easily found (no proprietary badged hubs that you need bearings for 10 years down the road and cannot find). J-bend spokes for the win. ERD of the st

[RBW] Re: Lightweight wheels question: J bend vs straight pull (Ritchey vs Hunt)

2023-01-16 Thread Andrew Turner
Wow yes, these look fantastic on paper. I actually went ahead and pulled the trigger on a set of them so I suppose we'll both see how things go. Thanks for the tip!! On Monday, January 16, 2023 at 3:44:22 PM UTC-6 pi...@gmail.com wrote: > I would consider Ted Neugent's wheels: > http://www.neug

[RBW] Re: Lightweight wheels question: J bend vs straight pull (Ritchey vs Hunt)

2023-01-16 Thread Piaw Na
I would consider Ted Neugent's wheels: http://www.neugentcycling.com/Alloy-Wheels.html The TwoX technology (16 drive side spokes, 8 non-drive side spokes so you can have equal tension of spokes on both sides, with washers on the non-drive side so you can tension them safely without the rim crac