Re: [RBW] Re: Let's talk about the All Rounder

2023-03-30 Thread Joe Bernard
Ok maybe I'm thinking that Starck worked at match before building Rivs. Beats me, there's a Joe Starck interview in a Reader that would explain stuff. On Thursday, March 30, 2023 at 1:32:09 PM UTC-7 Doug Van Cleve wrote: > Match was definitely after Joe Starck, my recollection is they were >

Re: [RBW] Re: Let's talk about the All Rounder

2023-03-30 Thread Doug Van Cleve
Match was definitely after Joe Starck, my recollection is they were brought online primarily because Joe could not keep up. While I was waiting for my bike, so around ‘99, the match announcement was made. I think match was making the relatively stock ones and Joe was making the more custom ones. Mi

Re: [RBW] Re: Let's talk about the All Rounder

2023-03-29 Thread Joe Bernard
Very strange. My memory is match was first - I think Starck was there at some point? - then he built on his own and for a while it was split between Starck and Curt Goodrich, then it was just Curt. Also this and that and the other thing happened, but I won't go over those old memories 😬 On We

Re: [RBW] Re: Let's talk about the All Rounder

2023-03-29 Thread rltilley
That’s strange. I received my All Rounder in June 2001 and it was a Starck build. He built it with 130 spacing in the rear rather than the 135 I specified so I had to take it back to him to fix it. He was local here and worked in the same building as Joe Bell. I still think about Joe Bell’s shop wi

Re: [RBW] Re: Let's talk about the All Rounder

2023-03-29 Thread iamkeith
Great first-hand info, John. I'd love to see a photo of your bike. From replies in this thread, and the timing they relay, I'm kind of starting to wonder if I don't have the last Joe Starck AR frame. I missed the drama at the time but hope he's doing well. On Wednesday, March 29, 2023 at 10:

Re: [RBW] Re: Let's talk about the All Rounder

2023-03-29 Thread EverRed
I ordered my AR in 1998 and got it in 1999. Between ordering it and receiving it the maker changed from Joe Stark to Match. GP wrote me a letter asking if it was okay to change. I wanted to stay with Joe but since it wasn’t possible I accepted Match. Mine is a 59 with 26 inch wheels but I th

Re: [RBW] Re: Let's talk about the All Rounder

2023-03-27 Thread Peter Adler
Bruce Gordon's mid-fork mounts are intended for Bruce's lowrider front rack, and for nothing else >:-P I built up my late lamented Raleigh International with BG front+rear racks, and had long intended to have contact points brazed on for them, along with pivot posts for centerpulls. I even soun

Re: [RBW] Re: Let's talk about the All Rounder

2023-03-26 Thread Joe Bernard
I wouldn't put too much stock in the date on the fork; the lugs, "speared" Rivendell decal and horizontal dropouts point to that frame being a pre-2000s All Rounder or possibly a Mountain..it's gorgeous! Clearances had widened by the time of your Atlantis. On Sunday, March 26, 2023 at 8:33:14 

Re: [RBW] Re: Let's talk about the All Rounder

2023-03-26 Thread luckyturnip
Pretty bike, interesting that the Super Yummys are snug, I have them on my 2004 Atlantis and they fit great. For whatever reason I assumed the AR would be more roomy. On Mar 26, 2023, at 18:46, vernon brooks wrote:I have been working on building up a recently purchased what I believe to be AR fra

[RBW] Re: Let's talk about the All Rounder

2023-03-25 Thread Ted Durant
As others have mentioned, talking about the All Rounder starts with the XO-n bikes from Bridgestone. Grant's daily commute between Walnut Creek and Bridgestone was a mix of paved and unpaved roads and trails over some pretty large hills. I would make a strong argument that the XO-n bikes were

[RBW] Re: Let's talk about the All Rounder

2023-03-25 Thread ascpgh
Sean, I'm biased because I had an XO and was happy with its versatility and ability to run tires up to 1.9" but the real test came when I agreed to join a group of three others to ride the TransAm in credit card mode in the summer of 2002. What you interpret the AR to be depends a lot on what yo

[RBW] Re: Let's talk about the All Rounder

2023-03-24 Thread Ryan
Classic! Do post when you're done. I'd love to see pictures of your X0-1 too, if you care to share Coleman Green? My 1997 A/R - waterford-built was painted Sherwood Green before Grant started using custom builders...but craftsmanship is definitely a few rungs above its X0-1 predecessor and the

Re: [RBW] Re: Let's talk about the All Rounder

2023-03-23 Thread Doug Van Cleve
Another plus, in 2023, is that most folks looking at pics of that bike probably assume those are 29er or 27.5 wheels and it belongs to a GIANT ;^) Doug On Thu, Mar 23, 2023 at 10:12 AM iamkeith wrote: > 4. Counter-balancing this, I think small-diameter tires on big frame (mine > is a 60cm) look

Re: [RBW] Re: Let's talk about the All Rounder

2023-03-23 Thread Steven Sweedler
Keith, very nice AR, i’m another who prefers 26” wheels. Steve On Thu, Mar 23, 2023 at 1:12 PM iamkeith wrote: > I've mentioned numerous times before that my All Rounder somehow remains > my go-to bike, no matter how many other road-ish bikes I acquire. I'm > really not entirely sure why, be

Re: [RBW] Re: Let's talk about the All Rounder

2023-03-23 Thread Doug Van Cleve
Pretty much what Joe said here, early RBW Waterford/Starck/Goodrich bikes generally only had seat stay mounts if that. My '99 Starck RS only has dropout eyelets. Very little about the current long chainstay, non-drop bar offerings relates at all to the early(ish) day designs. I would say really

Re: [RBW] Re: Let's talk about the All Rounder

2023-03-23 Thread James Valiensi
Hi, Well that is interesting. I had the impression they hadn’t done the rack mounts earlier, from the conversations I had with them when placing my order. Perhaps it was a rare request back then. Anyways - I am happy the mounts are more or less standard now a days, they are so useful! That gre

Re: [RBW] Re: Let's talk about the All Rounder

2023-03-23 Thread Steven Sweedler
I wonder when Nitto introduced the flexible strut mounts (Mark’s rack) vs. the rigid struts of the rack on Robert Tilleys AR. The 700 c AR that I had came with the same rack as Roberts. Bruce Gordon’s mid rack mounts were not compatible with that Nitto rack. Steve On Thu, Mar 23, 2023 at 8:22 AM G

Re: [RBW] Re: Let's talk about the All Rounder

2023-03-23 Thread Greg J
My recollection from one of the early Readers was that Grant felt that p-clamps worked just fine, and they didn't lock you into a single type of racks/fenders/what have you. A big part of the Riv philosophy is that these frames can be used for a long time and are not encumbered by fashion. As

Re: [RBW] Re: Let's talk about the All Rounder

2023-03-23 Thread Greg J
My recollection from one of the early Readers was that Grant felt that p-clamps worked just fine, and they offered more flexibility. A big part of the Riv philosophy is that these frames can be used for a long time and are not encumbered by fashion. As others have noted, all racks are differe

Re: [RBW] Re: Let's talk about the All Rounder

2023-03-22 Thread Joe Bernard
I could see that being a conversation in 2001. By the time I was drawing up my custom in 2019 Rivs had been running the Mark's Rack location for so long that when I specified "the mid-fork braze-ons" Grant knew what I meant. If I'd wanted something different to match traditional low-rider racks

Re: [RBW] Re: Let's talk about the All Rounder

2023-03-22 Thread rltilley
When I ordered my custom Riv I requested mounts for a front rack. Grant stated it was tough to place the braze-ons since each rack has unique attachment points. We settled on a location that works with the Nitto mini rack.  So maybe Grant feels p-clamps are able to work around various rack mounting

[RBW] Re: Let's talk about the All Rounder

2023-03-22 Thread Joe Bernard
Long wheelbase: I've ridden a bunch of both, they're both good but my custom is a longbike cuz it's MAGIC. What Grant's opinion was 20-25 years ago: has changed on a bunch of stuff. The first iteration of Atlantis didn't come with mid-fork mounts, now just about everything from the company doe

[RBW] Re: Let's talk about the All Rounder

2023-03-22 Thread R. Alexis
Hello all. I don't have an All Rounder, but I do have the first generation Waterford built Rivendell Mountain. Those first generation Rivendell Road, Allrounder and Mountain offered several options when ordering. Rack mount placement, Headtube extention, cream painted accent headtube, etc. I r

Re: [RBW] Re: Let's talk about the All Rounder

2023-03-22 Thread Brian Turner
I’d be curious to hear what sort of justification Grant had for claiming that p-clamps were superior to actual mid-fork braze ons. To me, a fixed mounting point seems like a secure no-brainer… less fiddly bits, no unsightly black rubber, and it looks so much cleaner.But then again, it wouldn’t surp

Re: [RBW] Re: Let's talk about the All Rounder

2023-03-22 Thread Junes
Hi m f, welcome! Congrats on the bike. Regarding your question: It seems odd to find an All Rounder, or any Riv for that matter, without rack mounts on the upper/mid fork blade. Would this have been a special request to not have them?It’s not totally unusual for Rivs, particularly early-ish ones, t

Re: [RBW] Re: Let's talk about the All Rounder

2023-03-22 Thread Andrew Letton
My Joe Stark '99 All-Rounder has rack mounts on the fork blades.  Was it maybe just that Curt had not yet done rack mounts on the fork blades for Rivs at that point?cheers,Andrew in Sydney On Thursday, March 23, 2023 at 11:02:02 AM GMT+11, James Valiensi wrote: Hi,When I ordered my cu

Re: [RBW] Re: Let's talk about the All Rounder

2023-03-22 Thread James Valiensi
Hi, When I ordered my custom Rivendell in 2002 I requested rack mounts on the fork blades. They hadn’t done this before. I had to send a drawing showing what I wanted. They agreed and Curt Goodrich made my frame. Joe Stark was supposed to be my builder, but he went of the reversvation before he

Re: [RBW] Re: Let's talk about the All Rounder

2022-03-20 Thread Patrick Moore
The All Rounder like the XO-1 before it gets a lot of interest and praise, but I think that, like the XO-1 that preceeded it, it is an early design that has been superseded and bettered by later Grantian bikes, starting with the Atlantis and continuing with the Sam Hillborne and doubtless the more

[RBW] Re: Let's talk about the All Rounder

2022-03-18 Thread Chris Zegers
Hi Sean, I had a an early Waterford A/R which was ordered in 1994 and I recieved it in 1995 (Burnt orange with gray flannel). One of the best bikes I owned and the one bike I wish I would've kept. In fact, I have a Nobilette built Rivendell influenced by that A/R w/700c wheels, which reminds

[RBW] Re: Let's talk about the All Rounder

2022-03-17 Thread iamkeith
I own an All Rounder. I also own a Saluki (pre-homer), a Ramboiillet, a Quickbeam, a Susie Longbolts (which replaced a Clem H), an XO-1, an RB-1, a late 90s Ibis Hakkaluggi, and more mountain bikes than possibly makes sense - including some that have been converted to road-ish bikes. Guess whi

Re: [RBW] Re: Let's talk about the All Rounder

2022-03-17 Thread Cyclofiend Jim
In terms of lineage, the A/R was the refinement of the XO from the Bridgestone era, and begat the Atlantis. http://www.cyclofiend.com/Images/rbw/gen1/rivcat05_allrounder.jpg http://www.cyclofiend.com/rbw/atlantis/index.html - J On Thursday, March 17, 2022 at 1:03:32 PM UTC-7 Ryan wrote: > Wh

Re: [RBW] Re: Let's talk about the All Rounder

2022-03-17 Thread Ryan
What Addison said! In my mind, it's like the little black Chanel cocktail dress...a classic that never really goes out of style. Think of Audrey Hepburn in *Breakfast at Tiffany's.* But of course, I too appreciate Riv's current offerings. Of course I'm keeping my 1997 Waterford-built AR. If I

[RBW] Re: Let's talk about the All Rounder

2022-03-17 Thread Sean Steinle
Thanks for the replies so far, wonderful stuff, this is exactly the sort of discussion I was hoping for. Unsurprisingly, the consensus so far seems to be what I thought from the start, a great bike, but less 'refined' than current Rivs, in the sense that Grant is always tweaking and making thing

[RBW] Re: Let's talk about the All Rounder

2022-03-17 Thread George Rosselle
I did not own and All Rounder but did have an Atlantis from the first batch. It was a beautiful bike and a pleasure to ride, but was a bit harsher than I would have liked. Maybe it would ride better loaded but I never rode it that way. I much prefer the ride of the Rosco Bubbe I have now. I thi

[RBW] Re: Let's talk about the All Rounder

2022-03-17 Thread Bill Lindsay
Sean asked a few questions regarding the All-Rounder. I have not owned one, but I know the Bridgestone and Riv history pretty well and know Grant pretty well. Sean's questions were: 1. I'm curious (about why it's a Holy Grail bike for several), is it simply the fact that they're rare and har

[RBW] Re: Let's talk about the All Rounder

2022-03-17 Thread Mackenzy Albright
I have not personally owned an all-rounder. But in general interest of bike development and history. It seemed that the design lineage came loosely from elements of the randonneur bikes (roadish geometry with 650b wider tires) Grant - being a thoughtful individual, adopted the design to contemp