Re: [RBW] Re: Big Guy Saddle Question

2011-05-31 Thread Tim McNamara
On May 31, 2011, at 9:01 AM, EricP wrote: > Am actually having enough problems with Brooks saddles at present that > am not riding them. Have given up trying to get things right. After > years of trying they just don't work for me. For some folks they just don't work. -- You received this me

[RBW] Re: Big Guy Saddle Question

2011-05-31 Thread Philip Williamson
I have no experience of VO saddles, but I put a new undercarriage on a Brooks recently. I used a small chisel to split the rivet, and a nail set to smash 'em down. I put a piece of wood on a heavy workbench as my "anvil." I didn't have to replace the nose rivets, just the ones on the rear. I bought

[RBW] Re: Big Guy Saddle Question

2011-05-31 Thread Thomas Lynn Skean
During a time through which I weighed ~250 I had a couple of B68s fail on me. I sit bolt upright; it's actually like I weigh more, I think. One failure may have been "my fault" in that I think I over-tensioned it; the nose bolt bent so much it became unusable and I had to replace it. By that time

[RBW] Re: Big Guy Saddle Question

2011-05-31 Thread Marc Irwin
I've 3 VO saddles and weigh 215 if I'm lucky, in September. I've no problems with them or the Brooks I have. Marc On May 31, 10:01 am, EricP wrote: > I'm 225 and have had a Model 6 for a year without problems.  (First > one had a rail weld fail. Replaced quickly without question.) > > A big dif

[RBW] Re: Big Guy Saddle Question

2011-05-31 Thread EricP
I'm 225 and have had a Model 6 for a year without problems. (First one had a rail weld fail. Replaced quickly without question.) A big difference between the VO and the Brooks is the shape. While the Brooks is concave in the middle, the VO is more humped. Possibly due to the lamination. It doe

[RBW] Re: Big Guy Saddle Question

2011-05-31 Thread Justin August
Goodwin's law needs a revision for the iBOB grouches. On May 31, 5:22 am, Brett Lindenbach wrote: > Hmmm, another cheap VO knockoff failing.  Why am I am not surprised?  You > could try to fix it with new rivets, bring it to a cobbler. -- You received this message because you are subscribed to

[RBW] Re: Big Guy Saddle Question

2011-05-31 Thread charlie
I have the same saddle and weigh exactly 268 dressed. No problems so far. I do use it though with noodle bars set high and most often ride the hoods. I also own a B66 on another bike and the VO saddle leather is stiffer and also has the reinforcing layer added underneath. I think a rivet redo is in