[RBW] Re: AR front brake shudder and fork flex

2011-02-20 Thread rw1911
Incredible response with a lot of great information and ideas for me to try. Thanks everyone. On Feb 18, 10:09 pm, rw1911 wrote: > I'm assuming (hoping) this is a simple setup issue... > > I've recently installed Paul brakes (neo-retro front, touring rear) on > my relatively new to me 700c All-

[RBW] Re: AR front brake shudder and fork flex

2011-02-20 Thread EricP
Not just angle, but also conditions. Today went for a 10 mile ride in a pretty serious winter storm. On downhills the front brake was not just useless, but dangerous. Got serious washout/lockup just touching it. Packed snow/ice will do that. First time in many that the downhills were slower th

[RBW] Re: AR front brake shudder and fork flex

2011-02-20 Thread Angus
m, but V-brake, disk brake, and > > > > > > caliper brake bikes can't have it. > > > > > > > If this had to do with toed in brake pads micro gripping and > > > > > > releasing, it would be equally common on all rim brake types. > >

[RBW] Re: AR front brake shudder and fork flex

2011-02-20 Thread Minh
I'm glad this came up, as i've been fighting slop in my front wheel for weeks and nearly destroyed my headset in the process. Now i think it could be what's described here (having not used cantis in a long time). For the fork crown hanger, i already have lots of stuff through my front fork crown

[RBW] Re: AR front brake shudder and fork flex

2011-02-20 Thread William
Gernot Funny you mention it. My most epic battles with shudder was on an Indy Fab also. At the time I hadn't learned about the crown hanger solution, but knowing it wasn't drilled excuses my ignorance (at least in my mind). I ended up just selling it, around the time the Hillborne came in to th

Re: [RBW] Re: AR front brake shudder and fork flex

2011-02-20 Thread CycloFiend
on 2/20/11 7:35 AM, Michael_S at mikeybi...@rocketmail.com wrote: > Angus, That's exactly my point. If you've ever ridden steep technical > terrain off road, you quickly learn never to apply significant > pressure to the front brake or you'll go right over the bars. In fact > you frequently use o

[RBW] Re: AR front brake shudder and fork flex

2011-02-20 Thread Michael_S
er brake bikes can't have it. > > > > > > If this had to do with toed in brake pads micro gripping and > > > > > releasing, it would be equally common on all rim brake types. > > > > > Furthermore, there is no free-body diagram one cou

[RBW] Re: AR front brake shudder and fork flex

2011-02-20 Thread Earl Grey
+2 on the fork crown hanger. The Tektro one works for me (Haven't tried the Specialized). Hhm, seems like all my braking hardware is Tektro these days. However, on a bike that had no through-hole through the fork crown (silly people at Indy Fab), I couldn't add a fork crown hanger and resorted to

[RBW] Re: AR front brake shudder and fork flex

2011-02-20 Thread Angus
ny kind squeezing harder on a rim will result > > > > in the brake pad squeezing LESS hard on the rim and allow it to > > > > release.  That's just not physically possible.  The sliding rim sort > > > > of shrugging the brakepad off of it, like some little

[RBW] Re: AR front brake shudder and fork flex

2011-02-19 Thread Michael_S
n the brake pad squeezing LESS hard on the rim and allow it to > > > release.  That's just not physically possible.  The sliding rim sort > > > of shrugging the brakepad off of it, like some little wrestling move > > > doesn't hold up. > > > > On Feb 19,

[RBW] Re: AR front brake shudder and fork flex

2011-02-19 Thread William
ing rim sort > > of shrugging the brakepad off of it, like some little wrestling move > > doesn't hold up. > > > On Feb 19, 1:33 pm, Tim McNamara wrote: > > > > On Feb 19, 2011, at 12:51 PM, Ray Shine wrote: > > > > > Excellent explanation. Even

[RBW] Re: AR front brake shudder and fork flex

2011-02-19 Thread Angus
t; > > > Excellent explanation. Even I could make sense of it!  Thank you! > > > > From: William > > > To: RBW Owners Bunch > > > Sent: Sat, February 19, 2011 9:36:14 AM > > > Subject: [RBW] Re: AR front brake shudder and fork flex > > > &

[RBW] Re: AR front brake shudder and fork flex

2011-02-19 Thread William
hold up. On Feb 19, 1:33 pm, Tim McNamara wrote: > On Feb 19, 2011, at 12:51 PM, Ray Shine wrote: > > > > > Excellent explanation. Even I could make sense of it!  Thank you! > > > From: William > > To: RBW Owners Bunch > > Sent: Sat, February 19, 2011 9:36

Re: [RBW] Re: AR front brake shudder and fork flex

2011-02-19 Thread CycloFiend
on 2/19/11 9:43 AM, Tim McNamara at tim...@bitstream.net wrote: >> This has cropped up on CX boards (and maybe iBob - too late to skim the >> archives there). The working theory (which seems pretty salient) is that >> flex in the hanger tends causing the shuddering. > > Flex in what hanger? Do y

Re: [RBW] Re: AR front brake shudder and fork flex

2011-02-19 Thread Tim McNamara
On Feb 19, 2011, at 12:51 PM, Ray Shine wrote: > Excellent explanation. Even I could make sense of it! Thank you! > > > From: William > To: RBW Owners Bunch > Sent: Sat, February 19, 2011 9:36:14 AM > Subject: [RBW] Re: AR front brake shudder and fork flex >

[RBW] Re: AR front brake shudder and fork flex

2011-02-19 Thread Ely Rodriguez
Excellent explanation Jim. I've had the same problem with tektro 720's on my ti rando with a ti fork. I played with different hangers, longer stem cable stop, changed the height of the hanger to shorten the amount of exposed cable between the stem cable stop and the hanger, I've toed in my brake sh

Re: [RBW] Re: AR front brake shudder and fork flex

2011-02-19 Thread omnigrid
* RBW Owners Bunch > *Sent:* Sat, February 19, 2011 9:36:14 AM > *Subject:* [RBW] Re: AR front brake shudder and fork flex > > This topic comes up repeatedly. The discussions typically focus on > treatment, which is natural, because you just want the thing to go > away. But understan

Re: [RBW] Re: AR front brake shudder and fork flex

2011-02-19 Thread Ray Shine
Excellent explanation. Even I could make sense of it! Thank you! From: William To: RBW Owners Bunch Sent: Sat, February 19, 2011 9:36:14 AM Subject: [RBW] Re: AR front brake shudder and fork flex This topic comes up repeatedly. The discussions typically

Re: [RBW] Re: AR front brake shudder and fork flex

2011-02-19 Thread MSmith
Someone Anonymous posted: "I've recently installed Paul brakes (neo-retro front, touring rear) on my relatively new to me 700c All-Rounder. The rears are wonderful, if not too powerful... I can skid at will. However, I'm experiencing extreme shudder and fork flex on the front." To which I repl

[RBW] Re: AR front brake shudder and fork flex

2011-02-19 Thread Peter Pesce
+1 for the fork crown hanger. Simplest fix. On Feb 19, 12:36 pm, William wrote: > This topic comes up repeatedly.  The discussions typically focus on > treatment, which is natural, because you just want the thing to go > away.  But understanding the cause is usually helpful in figuring out > th

[RBW] Re: AR front brake shudder and fork flex

2011-02-19 Thread Tim McNamara
On Feb 19, 2011, at 1:56 AM, CycloFiend wrote: > on 2/18/11 7:09 PM, rw1911 at rw1...@gmail.com wrote: >> I've recently installed Paul brakes (neo-retro front, touring rear) on >> my relatively new to me 700c All-Rounder. The rears are wonderful, if >> not too powerful... I can skid at will. H

[RBW] Re: AR front brake shudder and fork flex

2011-02-19 Thread William
This topic comes up repeatedly. The discussions typically focus on treatment, which is natural, because you just want the thing to go away. But understanding the cause is usually helpful in figuring out the treatment. The cause is as follows: You grab your front brake, which tries to stop the w

[RBW] Re: AR front brake shudder and fork flex

2011-02-19 Thread MikeC
My experience is the same as Angus's. My CR720's fit very loosely on the studs and when the pads contact the rim they pivot on the studs enough to go toe out if you do not set up the pads to be toe-in under contact and rotational load. Cured the violent low-speed shudder for me. -Mike C On Feb 19

[RBW] Re: AR front brake shudder and fork flex

2011-02-19 Thread Angus
I had a set or Ribbit (typical Cyclocross brakes, Mafac copies) on my Atlantis that did a very similar thing. I am not familiar with Paul's brakes so this may not apply (some brakes have an internal bushing and don't have a bushing riding directly on the cantilever post on the frame). Also Jim ma