Re: [R] Fixed effects regression and robust regression

2015-05-20 Thread S Ellison
> since the OLS and robust regressions have the same number of DFs, looking > at the residual standard error is insightful. Sadly not. The residual scale in a robust model is only partly indicative of goodness of fit; robust models intentionally downweight outliers. Much of the difference in

Re: [R] Fixed effects regression and robust regression

2015-05-19 Thread Bert Gunter
On Tue, May 19, 2015 at 1:23 PM, michael westphal via R-help wrote: You can't compare them (statistically -- you can of course draw pictures). Note, from ?rlm: " Note that the df.residual component is deliberately set to NA to avoid inappropriate estimation of the residual scale from the residua

[R] Fixed effects regression and robust regression

2015-05-19 Thread michael westphal via R-help
Hello: I am using R 3.0.2.   I have panel data on countries' renewable energy net generation (and installed capacity) over time.  I am regressing these dependent variables on various socioeconomic variables, as well as binary policy variables.  I have have done basic OLS, but I wanted to explore